Home Archive
Archive
2024 Volume 53 Issue 9  Published: 2024-09-25
    Overview of long-term energy storage technology
  • Wenping JU , Yifan WANG , Yong ZHAO , Xiaojun XIE
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202405093

    With the increasing penetration rate of renewable energy in China’s power system in the future, the stability of the system will face more severe challenges. Long-term energy storage technology plays an important role in balancing grid demand, improving grid stability, promoting the consumption of renewable energy, and promoting green and low-carbon development in the power system. Long-term energy storage has a wide range of application scenarios on the power supply side, grid side, and load side of the system, which is of great significance for the development of China’s new power system. Firstly, the characteristics and development trends of the current new power system are introduced, and the supporting role of long-term energy storage technology in the new power system is analyzed. Then, the technical principles and routes of five long-term energy storage technologies, such as the compressed air energy storage, lithium-ion battery energy storage, liquid flow battery energy storage, molten salt energy storage, and hydrogen energy storage, are summarized. The advantages and disadvantages of various long-term energy storage technologies are also analyzed. Finally, the future application prospects of long-term energy storage technology in the new power system are discussed.

  • Overview of long-term energy storage technology
  • Qing HE , Jinfeng SHI , Mingxiang JIA
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202401002

    The compressed air energy storage is a large-scale physical energy storage technology and a highly promising new type of energy storage technology. This paper summarizes the basic principles of isothermal compressed air energy storage, and introduces the principles and current development status of key equipment and related technologies. It provides an analysis and summary of liquid pistons, pumps and turbines. Moreover, it reviews the basic principles of isothermal compressed air energy storage, and analyzes the existing research progress on isothermal compressed air energy storage technology. An analysis and summary are presented for liquid piston technology, as well as pump and turbine technology in the system. The data of existing compressed air energy storage power stations are summarized and analyzed. The data of existing compressed air energy storage power stations are summarized and analyzed. On this basis, the future development direction of isothermal compressed air energy storage technology is prospected, which provides a certain data reference for the selection of power equipment in isothermal compressed air energy storage system and the promotion of demonstration projects.

  • Compressed air energy storage technology
  • Yao ZHANG , Yilun ZHANG , Chuanqi SU , Zhan LIU
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202404058

    Accelerating the transformation of energy structure and promoting the grid connection of renewable energy power generation is an important initiative to address climate change and the development of renewable energy. Energy storage technology can improve the stability of power grid and enhance the utilization rate of renewable energy. Among the energy storage technologies, compressed air energy storage has been widely studied for its high efficiency, low investment cost and environmental friendliness. Compared with the conventional constant-capacity compressed air energy storage technology, isobaric compressed air energy storage avoids the unavoidable buffer air in the constant-capacity compressed air energy storage system, enables the compressor and expander to operate efficiently at constant discharge pressure, and eliminates the throttling loss in front of the expander unit. The advantages of isobaric compressed air energy storage technologies are introduced, and the isobaric compressed air energy storage technologies are classified into underwater compressed air energy storage, pumping-compensated compressed air energy storage, solid-compensated compressed air energy storage, and gas-phase-change-compensated compressed air energy storage. Moreover, the basic principles, research progress and challenges of the above four types of isobaric compressed air energy storage technologies are discussed. Finally, the development of the isobaric compressed air energy storage technologies is prospected.

  • Compressed air energy storage technology
  • Guanhua SUN , Xuan GENG , Xianyang YU , Lipeng WANG , Jicheng DUAN , Zhenhua WANG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202403051

    In order to explore the type of underground cavern with compressed air energy storage from the perspective of thermodynamics, a numerical model of the first inflation and pressurization process of the cavern considering turbulence, heat transfer and real air characteristics is established, by using the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) method. The effects of different length-diameter ratios and inlet diameters of inflatable pipes on temperature rise of gas and lining materials in the cavern and the temperature distribution in the cavern are studied, and the control measures are put forward for the local high temperature phenomenon in the cavern. The main conclusions are as follows. When the length-diameter ratio is small (large tank gas storage), the temperature distribution in the cavern is relatively uniform. With the increase of the ratio of length to diameter (tunnel-type gas storage), the temperature distribution in the cavern appears stratification phenomenon, and the extremely high temperature zone appears at the end of the cavern (stuffy top effect). The temperature rise of the steel plate sealing layer is the largest in the process of inflation and pressurization of the cavern, the temperature change of the concrete lining is small, and the surrounding rock is almost not affected by temperature change in the cavern. Reducing the inlet diameter of the inflatable pipe can reduce the temperature in the cavern to a certain extent and promote the outward heat transfer. For the annular tunnel type cavern, the proposed improved inflation method can make the temperature distribution in the cavern uniform, avoid the stuffy roof effect, and provide a useful reference for engineering design.

  • Compressed air energy storage technology
  • Mengjie ZHANG , Qiang LIU , Tonghe ZHANG , Yongxing SONG , Linhua ZHANG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202404070

    The arrangement of micro adiabatic compressed air energy storage (A-CAES) system is flexible and suitable for typical distributed energy systems. By accurately modelling a typical device of the miniature A-CAES system based on pneumatic motors, a thermodynamic model that can reflect its system performance is constructed. The experimental bench of the A-CAES system is built, and the average error rate between the simulation model and the experiment is around 5.38%, which verifies the reliability of the model. The round-trip efficiency and comprehensive efficiency of the system are 4.81% and 27.23%, respectively, verifying the necessity of the existence of thermal energy storage devices in the A-CAES system. The effects of compression level and compression ratio on the system performance are analyzed by using this model. The results show that, as the compression level increases, the round-trip efficiency and comprehensive efficiency of the system both increase, and the optimal efficiency of the system can reach 6.10% and 35.81%, respectively. Taking the combination of compression ratios of 2, 3, and 5 as an example, reasonable distribution of compression ratios can improve the round-trip efficiency and overall efficiency of the system by 1.27% and 4.38%, respectively.

  • Compressed air energy storage technology
  • Gao XU , Fangyi XIE , Zhenrui CAO , Xingyuan ZHAO , Jianhua CUI , Shaofeng HAN , Qing HE
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202311181

    At present, the construction technology of salt cavern gas storage has been mature, and it is developing in the direction of intelligence. Based on the technical status of salt cavern gas storage, the current construction technologies of salt cavern gas storage are analyzed. From the perspective of whole life cycle management, the intelligent construction of salt cavern gas storage is divided into four stages: intelligent location, intelligent design, intelligent construction and intelligent operation and maintenance, and the key technologies involved in each stage are studied. The technical framework of intelligent construction technology of salt cavern gas storage and its specific content is put forward. Moreover, the future research focus of intelligent construction of salt cavern gas storage is proposed and summarized from four aspects: system, technology, theory and model. The relevant technologies have been effectively applied in Yingcheng 300 MW compressed air energy storage demonstration project.

  • Compressed air energy storage technology
  • Zhirong JIANG , Zhongbo HU , Kong YU , Yubin LI , Chao LIU , Hong LI , Qing HE
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202405111

    A wind-drove compressed air energy storage (W-CAES) system is proposed, its main advantage is that it can reduce the waste of wind energy caused by the fluctuation and randomness of wind energy. The direct-driven compressor of wind turbine gets rid of the dependence of compressor on the input electricity, which is more suitable for off-grid power generation system. The model of the W-CAES system is established, the parameters of the wind turbine direct-drive compressed air energy storage system are designed, and the effects of wind speed, ambient temperature, and air humidity on efficiency of the system are analyzed. The results show that, the filling time increases with the decrease of wind speed with the same storage volume, and the filling times are 0.71 h and 1.64 h when the wind speeds are 14 m/s and 6 m/s, respectively. The system efficiency decreases slightly with the increase of ambient temperature and air humidity. When the ambient temperatures are -30 ℃ and 40 ℃, the corresponding system efficiencies are 52.97% and 52.08%, respectively. When the relative humidity of the air is 0 and 1, the corresponding system efficiencies are 52.27% and 52.14%, respectively.

  • Liquid air energy storage technology
  • Junxian LI , Yanjiang LIU , Kun LIU , Zhaozhao GAO , Liubiao CHEN , Junjie WANG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202406126

    Liquid air energy storage (LAES) is a promising technology for large-scale energy storage due to its geographical flexibility and high energy storage density. To further improve the round-trip efficiency and economic benefits of LAES, a novel integrated system combining liquid natural gas (LNG) cold energy utilization and organic Rankine cycle (ORC) with LAES is proposed. Thermodynamic and economic analysis methods for the integrated system are established, and the effects of key parameters on the system’s thermal performance are investigated based on simulations. An economic analysis of the system is also conducted. The results show that, as the system’s expansion pressure increases, both efficiency and power output rise, but at a decreasing rate. The system’s round-trip efficiency increases with more expansion stages up to a point, then decreases. With four-stage expansion, the system efficiency reaches 62.26%, which is 7%~12% higher than that of the conventional LAES system. When the difference between peak and valley electricity prices is 0.848 yuan/(kW·h), the net present value, dynamic payback period, and levelized cost of electricity are 119 058 500 yuan, 4.48 years, and 0.893 yuan/(kW·h), respectively. The results of this study can provide a reference for engineering application and efficiency improvement of LAES systems.

  • Liquid air energy storage technology
  • Yihong LI , Jiyun LIU , Baokun LI , Zhaozhao GAO , Liubiao CHEN , Junjie WANG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202406125

    Liquid air energy storage (LAES) technology stands out as a large-scale energy storage technology due to its superior energy storage density and adaptability to external energy sources. An LAES system that recovers waste cold of liquid ethylene and introduces an external low-temperature heat source is proposed. Moreover, thermodynamical and economic analysis on key parameters, including isentropic efficiency of the compressor and expander, and temperature of the heat source, are conducted. The results reveal that, when the ethylene flow rate is 34 t/h, the energy storage capacity can reach up to 5 MW/40 (MW·h). At isentropic efficiency of the compressor and expander of 90%, the round-trip efficiency can achieve 77.45% by solely relying on an ambient heat source of 25 ℃ for air heating. When the heat source temperature is increased to 125 °C, the system’s optimal round-trip efficiency, net present value, and dynamic payback period reaches 106.99%, 144.73 million yuan, and 3.56 years, respectively. These findings provide reference for research on the coupling of LAES systems with external cold energy.

  • Liquid air energy storage technology
  • Jiyun LIU , Xindong WANG , Zi LIN , Zhaowei JIANG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202406124

    The intermittency and volatility of renewable energy poses significant challenges to stable operation of power grids. Energy storage technology can address these issues effectively. Liquid air energy storage technology offers significant advantages of high energy storage density, being unconstrained by geographical conditions and atmospheric pressure storage. However, its round-trip efficiency is relatively low. To solve this problem, a liquid nitrogen and liquid air hybrid energy storage system (N-LAES) is proposed. By charging liquid nitrogen during energy release process, the gas flow in the expander increases, and gas pressure in front of the expander rises as well, thus the system’s round-trip efficiency increases. A thermodynamic model is developed, and the analysis results indicate that, for a typical scale N-LAES, the round-trip efficiency is increased to 66.47% compared with 56.90% for a standalone LAES. The net present value at the 30th year increases to 120 213 500 yuan, compared with 58 077 400 yuan for a standalone LAES, and the levelized cost of storage decreases to 0.809 4 yuan/(kW·h) from 0.897 2 yuan/(kW·h) for a standalone LAES. These findings demonstrate that both the thermodynamic and economic performance of the N-LAES is superior to that of the standalone LAES, offering a new approach for development of the liquid air energy storage technology.

  • Liquid air energy storage technology
  • Zhenxin SUN , Haizhao LI , Zhiming ZHANG , Fubo MA , Congjin JIANG , Chaoqun ZHANG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202404081

    “Power entropy” can quantitatively reflect the characteristic difference of multi-time scale energy storage configuration. The power curve synthesized by two sinusoidal power curves is used to study the entropy difference and characteristics of main scenarios of energy storage applications such as frequency regulation, peak regulation and cross-season energy regulation. The results show that, power entropy can effectively reflect the difference of characteristics of energy storage for different time scales. For the scenarios of frequency regulation and peak regulation, using two sets of energy storage is better. For the scenarios that the difference between frequency and amplitude is less than 2 times, it is appropriate to apply a single set of energy storage. The research theoretically explores the methods and basis of multi-time scale energy storage configuration, reveals the essential differences of multi-time scale problems, it is helpful to form a scientific and optimal energy storage configuration scheme, scheduling scheme and optimization scheme.

  • Hydrogen storage technology
  • Zeqi CHEN , Hongmei CAO , Zhongyu TIAN , Min ZHANG , Shiming ZHU , Detai SHI , Ming GAO
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202404071

    To explore the heat and mass transfer process in a solid-state hydrogen storage reactor, a two-dimensional numerical calculation model for the reactor is developed. The radial reaction rate distribution characteristics of the solid-state hydrogen storage material within the reactor is investigated, and the influence laws of bed thickness of the hydrogen storage material and diameter of the heat exchange tube on saturation radius are also studied. Based on this, the arrangement of the heat exchange tube bundle is optimized. The results show that, the heat exchange tube has the corresponding maximum saturation radius, and it increases with the tube radius. When the tube radius is 1.00~6.00 mm with single-tube arrangement, the maximum saturation radius is 2.60, 3.30, 3.50, 3.70, 3.80 and 3.90 mm, respectively. The volume fraction of heat exchange tubes with radius of 1.00, 2.00 and 3.00 mm is relatively small, which is 7.72%, 14.24% and 21.30%. The optimal bed thickness between tubes is 4.86, 6.09 and 6.38 mm when arranging the above three types of tubes in a tube bundle. Moreover, adding heat exchange tube bundles can effectively improve the hydrogen storage performance of reaction dead zone in the reactor. In the reactor equipped with heat exchange tube bundles with radius of 2.00 mm, adding 12 heat exchange tubes with radius of 2.00 mm in the reaction deadzone can reduce the hydrogen storage time to 267 s (by 40.00%), while the volume fraction of tube bundle only increases by 1.92%, and the hydrogen storage capacity just decreases by 2.17%. The research findings can establish a fundamental basis for the optimal design of solid-state hydrogen storage reactors and offer valuable guidance for subsequent engineering applications.

  • Hydrogen storage technology
  • Shaobin ZHOU , Hongmei CAO , Ning FU , Min ZHANG , Fengrui GUO , Xiaolong WANG , Ming GAO
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202403057

    Latent heat thermal energy storage technology can realize recovery and supply of heat during solid-state hydrogen storage and release process, achieving self-thermal balance inside the solid-state hydrogen storage tank, and improve the hydrogen storage and release performance. For horizontal tube and shell latent heat thermal energy storage exchanger, a new movement method where the inner tube is placed eccentrically to rotate around the central axis is proposed. By the Fluent software, the user-defined function UDF is written using the dynamic mesh technique, and the influence of eccentric distance and rotation velocity of the inner tube on heat storage performance is focused. The results show that, compared with the conventional static arrangement of the central inner tube, the rotation movement of the eccentric inner tube can improve the heat storage performance significantly. The heat storage time reaches the shortest when the eccentric distance is 9 mm and the rotation velocity is 0.10 r/min, namely decreases by 92.16%, and the time average heat storage rate increases by 11.51 times. The heat storage time reduces by 13.57% when the eccentric distance is 9 mm and the rotation velocity is decreased from 0.30 r/min to 0.1 r/min, it decreases by 70.48% when the rotation velocity is 0.10 r/min and the eccentric distance is increased from 3 mm to 9 mm. The study results can provide a new idea for performance optimization of horizontal shell and tube latent heat thermal energy storage exchangers in hydrogen storage field.

  • Hydrogen storage technology
  • Xiaotong XI , Shen TIAN , Luna GUO , Liubiao CHEN , Chengyang XU , Weichen XU , Zhili SUN
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202405108

    Hydrogen storage by physical adsorption offers significant advantages, including high safety, high hydrogen storage density, and fast hydrogen charging and discharging rates, making it a highly promising method for hydrogen storage. Among the various materials, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as ideal hydrogen storage materials due to their highly ordered porous structures and tunable characteristics. To investigate the influence of thermal effects during the hydrogen adsorption process on storage performance, a numerical model of hydrogen storage by adsorption is established and validated. Subsequently, the hydrogen storage properties of Cu-BTC and activated carbon AX-21 tanks are analyzed and compared. Furthermore, the hydrogen storage capacity of Cu-BTC tank at different temperatures is explored. The results indicate that, compared with AX-21, the hydrogen storage capacity at room temperature increases by 12.8% when using Cu-BTC as adsorbent. When the storage temperature is reduced to 77 K, the maximum pressure in the Cu-BTC tank decreases to 0.97 MPa, and the hydrogen storage capacity increases by 174% compared with room temperature (300 K). These findings provide valuable insights for further research on the hydrogen storage capabilities of Cu-BTC materials.

  • Hydrogen storage technology
  • Fanqi MENG , Peng WANG , Haili WANG , Li XIN
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202403049

    Affected by the rapid electricity load growth and the increase of water uncertainty under extreme weather conditions, the contradiction between supply-side and demand-side volatility in areas with high hydropower proportion has become increasingly prominent. The demand for flexible resources with long-term regulation capability is becoming more urgent. Hydrogen energy storage with long-term regulation capacity can alleviate the tense situation of supply and demand in areas with high proportion of hydropower. The research designs an optimal allocation model of electric-hydrogen hybrid energy storage, which is suitable for areas with high hydropower proportion. The loss of load penalty function is introduced into the objective function, and the variation of generation capacity of large/small and medium-sized hydropower units with time is quantified. By taking the power system composed of 96 different types of generators in a high hydropower proportion area as the object, analysis is performed. Compared with the current energy storage configuration requirements, the optimization result of the model increases the hydropower consumption by 7 188 MW·h, reduces the unloaded electricity by 6 513 MW·h, and reduces the total cost by 3.194 million yuan. Moreover, the demand scale of different types of energy storage and the income of energy storage enterprises in high hydropower area, high thermal power area and high new energy area are compared horizontally. The relevant conclusions can provide reference for the development of energy storage investment in the future.

  • Hydrogen storage technology
  • Zhenyu DENG , Jiahui ZHOU , Gang XU , Runzhi ZHANG , Xiaona SONG
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202401011

    In order to reduce the fluctuation of renewable energy power generation output and improve the utilization rate of renewable energy, this paper designs an on/off grid wind solar hybrid hydrogen synthesis ammonia system. Taking the maximum annual revenue of the system as the objective function, considering the operation constraints such as power balance, hydrogen balance and grid interaction, a capacity allocation scheduling optimization model is established. Taking the real output of the wind and solar energy in a certain area of Inner Mongolia as the input, through the analysis on wind and solar energy capacity ratio, this paper explores the technical and economic effect of the wind and solar energy capacity ratio on the system. The results show that, after the capacity configuration and scheduling optimization of the on/off grid wind solar complementary hydrogen and ammonia system, the system can reasonably switch the working state under different wind and solar output conditions, stabilize the wind and solar fluctuations, and realize the stable and efficient operation of ammonia equipment. The grid connected system is better than the off grid system. Through the analysis of the ratio of wind and solar capacity, in the case area, with the increase of wind capacity, the capacity of electrolyzer and hydrogen storage tank to be configured in the system shows a trend of first decreasing and then increasing. When the capacity of wind power generation and photovoltaic power generation is close to or equal, the economic efficiency of the system is high.

  • Hydrogen storage technology
  • Pengxiang ZHAO , Jialin YANG , Xian YANG , Lin CONG , Chengyou LYU
    doi: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202312187

    Solid oxide cells have the ability to switch between electrolysis and fuel cell power generating modes, and operate at 650~850 ℃, resulting in high-grade waste heat. The equipment utilization ratio and energy utilization efficiency can be significantly increased by using the cell for the tri-generation of heat, electricity, and hydrogen. A photovoltaic and concentrated solar heat driven solid oxide cell system for tri-generation system of heat, power, and hydrogen is presented, and molten salt thermal storage system and batteries are coupled to ensure continuous and stable operation of solid oxide cell. By taking the lowest total cost as the object, a mixed integer linear programming model for system capacity configuration and operation strategy optimization is constructed. Moreover, based on the energy consumption principle of cascade utilization, the pinch analysis approach is applied to maximize the cascade use of multi-grade energy flows throughout the entire system, providing an efficient mechanism for integrating mass and energy in coupled systems. For a real case of solar energy resources and heat, electricity, hydrogen requirement in an industrial park, the coupled system’s levelized energy cost is 0.28 yuan/kW, and the annual full load operating hours of the solid oxide cell reaches over 6 000 h.