Chinese Traditional and Herbal Drugs
|
2025, 56(11): 3974-3984
Discussion on applicability of common association and cluster analysis methods to traditional Chinese medicine prescription data
Full
ZHANG Di1, CHEN Yihuan2, ZHANG Weina1
Affiliations
1 Institute of Information on Traditional Chinese Medicine, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing 100700, China;
2 Institute of Basic Research in Clinical Medicine, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing 100700, China
doi: 10.7501/j.issn.0253-2670.2025.11.018
Outline
Objective To investigate the applicability of common association and clustering analysis methods to traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) prescription data, and propose an optimal framework for association and clustering analysis in TCM prescription data mining research based on existing methods. Methods By considering the characteristics of TCM prescription data, this study identifies mismatches between analytical methods and TCM prescription data at the algorithmic principle level. Typical real-world research examples are presented to demonstrate potential unreasonable phenomena in the application of different methods. For methods with optimization potential, improved application approaches are proposed. For association analysis methods, a comparative evaluation of all algorithms is conducted using real medical case data to highlight differences in computational outcomes. Results Besides Pearson, Spearman, and Phi correlation coefficients, all drug association analysis methods exhibit varying degrees of limitations when applied to TCM prescription data. Comparative experiments revealed the following issues: Support and confidence metrics overestimate results for high-frequency drugs; Euclidean and Hamming distances tend to overestimate associations between low-frequency drugs; cosine similarity and Jaccard coefficient yield underestimated results for drug combinations with significant frequency disparities; mutual information and modified mutual information produce abnormal results for nearly all combinations; and lift underestimates results for high-frequency drugs. Among common drug clustering methods, hierarchical clustering and maximal clique algorithms demonstrate the best partitioning performance, though the former may include low-relevance drugs in clusters, while the latter produces overly ambiguous category divisions. After optimization, the limitations ofhierarchical clustering and maximal clique-based algorithms were mitigated. Conclusion For drug association calculations, Pearson, Spearman, and Phi correlation coefficients could be prioritized. In drug clustering analysis, the optimized application methods can be adopted: hierarchical clustering is recommended to analyze the agglomeration process of drug categories, whereas the maximal clique algorithm can be used to identify multidimensional application directions of drugs.
traditional Chinese medicine
/
prescription
/
data mining
/
association analysis
/
Pearson correlation coefficient
/
Spearman correlation coefficient
/
Phi correlation coefficient
/
system cluster analysis
/
maximal cliplet algorithm
张迪, 陈艺幻, 张伟娜.
常用关联与聚类分析方法对中医处方数据的适用性探讨.
中草药,
2025
, 56
(11)
: 3974
-3984
.
DOI: 10.7501/j.issn.0253-2670.2025.11.018
ZHANG Di, CHEN Yihuan, ZHANG Weina.
Discussion on applicability of common association and cluster analysis methods to traditional Chinese medicine prescription data[J].
Chinese Traditional and Herbal Drugs,
2025
, 56
(11)
: 3974
-3984
.
DOI: 10.7501/j.issn.0253-2670.2025.11.018
Year 2025 volume 56 Issue 11
51
7
Cite this Article
BibTeX
Article Info
doi: 10.7501/j.issn.0253-2670.2025.11.018
- Receive Date:2025-03-21
- Online Date:2026-11-13