In order to demonstrate the synthetic values of this domino reaction, various arylidene Meldrum acids
5 were also tested in the three-component reaction under same reaction conditions. The results are summarized in
Table 2. Although the similar spiro compounds were obtained in this reaction, the reactions with arylidene Meldrum acids gave very different regioselectivity and diastereoselectivity to that of the above mentioned reaction with arylidene
N,
N'-dimethylbarbituric acids. At first, different from the formation of spiro compounds with aryl group and methoxycarbonyl group at 1, 3-positions in the reaction of arylidene
N,
N'-dimethylbarbituric acids, the spiro compounds with aryl group and 3-methoxycarbonyl group at 1, 2-positions were obtained in the reaction containing arylidene Meldrum acids. Secondly, the reaction usually gave
trans-2, 3-disubstituted 6, 10- dioxo-7, 9-dioxaspiro[4.5]dec-1-enes
6a-6g as main products and
cis-2, 3-6, 10-dioxo-7, 9-dioxaspiro[4.5]dec-1-enes
7a-7g as minor products. In the reaction of benzylidene Meldrum acid, the expected
cis-isomer
7a was not obtained due to too lower yield. However, only
cis-isomer
7c was obtained in the reaction of
o-methoxybenzylidene Meldrum acid, while the expected
trans-isomer
6c was not successfully isolated. It should be pointed out that a mixture of
cis/
trans-isomers with similar molecular ratios were also obtained when the three-component reaction was carried out in other solvent such as dimethoxyethane, tetrahydrofuran and acetonitrile, The structures of the obtained
cis/
trans-isomers
6a-6g and
7a-7g were fully characterized by IR, HRMS,
1H,
13C and
31P NMR spectroscopies. The
1H NMR spectra of the
cis/
trans-isomers give very different patterns of the characteristic absorptions. For example, the
1H NMR spectrum of
6b shows a singlet at
δ 4.40 and a mixed peak at
δ 4.12-4.03 for the three protons in cyclopentene ring. The three methoxy group give three singlets at
δ 3.27,
δ 2.96,
δ 2.27, the one methyl groups in propylene unit shows a normal peak at
δ 1.79, while the sign of another methyl group shifts to the high magnetic field at
δ 0.60 due to effect of ring current of phenyl group. In the
1H NMR spectrum of
7b, the three protons on the ring of cyclopentene display a singlet at
δ 4.77, and two doublets at
δ 4.20,
δ 3.96. The three methoxy group display three singlets at
δ 2.98,
δ 2.85,
δ 2.25 and two methyl groups show two singlets at 1.88 and
δ 1.80. The single crystal structures of the three-couples of
cis/
trans-isomers
6b (
Fig. 2),
7b (
Fig. 3),
6f, 7f, 6g and
7g (Figs. S2-S5 in Supporting information) were successfully determined by X-ray diffraction method. Crystallographic data
6b (CCDC No. 1907400),
6f (CCDC No. 1907401),
6g (CCDC No.1907402),
7b (CCDC No.1907403),
7f (CCDC No. 1907404),
7g (CCDC No. 1907405) have been deposited at the Cambridge Crystallographic Data base Centre. From the
Fig. 1, it is clearly observed that the 2-aryl group and 3-methoxycarbonyl group exist in
trans-configuration in spiro compound
6b. The one methyl group actually stands on the upper position of phenyl ring, which causes its absorption shifting to a high magnetic field in
1H NMR spectrum. On the other hand, the 2-aryl group and 3-methoxycarbonyl group exist on cis-configuration in spiro compound
7b. The two methyl groups do not exist on the top of phenyl ring. Thus, the two methyl groups give the normal absorption peaks in
1H NMR spectrum.