Following our initially reported result [
50], we began the investigation of twelve different metal salts by evaluating the annulation of
N-diethoxyphosphoryl spirocyclopropyl oxindoles
2a with
1 under the reported condition (10 mol% of metal catalyst, 1, 2-dichloroethane (DCE) as solvent at room temperature) (
Table 1). Among them (for full details, please see Table S1 in Supporting information), Mg(OTf)
2, Ni(OTf)
2, Cu(OTf)
2, Zn(OTf)
2, La(OTf)
3, Y(OTf)
3, Er(OTf)
3, Yb(OTf)
3, Bi(OTf)
3 did not work at all, and only In(OTf)
3, Sc(OTf)
3 and Ga(OTf)
3 could promote the [3 + 3] annulation, affording the desired product
3a with moderate to good diastereoselectivities (entries 1–3). Different from known examples whereas Sc(OTf)
3 behaves superior for this type of cycloaddition [
56,
57], In(OTf)
3 gives better result in terms of efficiency and diastereoselectivity in our case (entry 1
vs. 2). Encouraged by this, we further evaluated the solvent effect with In (OTf)
3 as the optimal catalyst. It turns out that dichloromethane (DCM) was the best choice and product
3a can be isolated with excellent yield and 5:1 dr (entries 1, 4–8) within only 1 h. However, attempts to further decreasing the catalyst loading or lowering reaction temperature failed by the observation of lower yields (entries 9 and 10). During the condition optimization, we also noticed that the ratio of diastereoselectivity decreased gradually as the reaction went on and no changed (dr = 2.8:1) was observed after 24 h (entry 11), which might be caused by the conversion of kinetic product to thermodynamic one, and indicated that the reaction should be quenched in time in order to prohibiting the undesired epimerization. Therefore, the optimized condition entailed the utilization of
2 (0.15 mmol),
1 (0.09 mmol), In(OTf)
3 (10 mol%) as catalyst in DCM at room temperature and the typical procedure of the [3 + 3] cyclization reaction was as follow: to a Schlenk tube was sequentially added In(OTf)
3 (8.4 mg, 0.015 mmol, 10 mol%), oxindole
2 (0.15 mmol), 1, 4-dithiane-2, 5-diol
1 (0.09 mmol) and anhydrous CH
2Cl
2 (1.5 mL). After the resulting solution was stirred at 25 ℃ for the indicated time, the residue was rapidly passed through a glass funnel with a thin layer (5 mm) of silica gel (100 mesh), eluted with CH
2Cl
2, and concentrated under reduced pressure. To determine the diastereoselectivity of product, the residue was first dissolved in CDCl
3, and took some samples for the determination of diastereoselectivity by NMR analysis. Then the sample for analysis and the rest of the product were recombined for column chromatographic purification using petroleum ether/EtOAc (1/1, v/v) as the eluent to afford the desired products
3.