To validate our hypothesis, we started our study by using 4-bromoaniline (
1a) and 2, 2-dimethoxyacetaldehyde (
2a) as model substrates. Initially, the reaction was performed in 1, 4-dioxane under air. No reaction occurred in the absence of catalyst (
Table 1, entry 1). When strong Lewis acids, Sc(OTf)
3 and AlCl
3, were used as catalysts, it is difficult to initiate the reaction neither (entries 2 and 3). When a stoichiometric amount of a weak Lewis acid, MnCl
2, was added,
N-(4-bromophenyl)formamide
3a was formed exclusively, however, the yield reached only 23% after 2 h of reaction at 80℃ (entry 4). The yield of
3a can be improved to 42% by using Fe(OTf)
3 as a catalyst (entry 5). PTSA exhibited excellent catalytic activity for this reaction, with which
3a can be obtained in 65% yield (entry 6). Subsequently, the effect of solvent was investigated by using PTSA as catalyst. Only trace amount of
3a was detected when toluene was used as solvent (entry 7). The reaction proceeded hardly in acetonitrile and nitromethane (entries 8 and 9). When DMSO was employed as solvent,
1a was converted quickly. However, three products, including
3a, methyl phenylglycinate (
4aa) and dimethyl 2, 2′-(phenylazanediyl)diacetate (
4ba), were isolated with a product distribution in favor of the latter two (entry 10). The reaction proceeded also smoothly in chloroform with
4ba been formed as the major product, and after 2h of reaction, its yield reached 40% along with simultaneous isolation of 19% of
4aa and 5% of
3a (entry 11). We next changed many other parameters in order to maximize the yield of each reaction pathway. The uses of an excess amount of
1a and a protection with oxygen balloon were proved to be helpful for improving the selectivity to
3a (entries 12–14). These observations guided us to find conditions A to synthesize
3a, that are PTSA catalyst, 1, 4-dioxane solvent, a 2.0/1.0 ratio of
1a/
2a, protection with O
2 balloon, 2h and 60℃. Under these conditions,
3a can be isolated in 84% yield (entry 14). Somehow, performing the reaction at a higher temperature, 80℃, imposed a negative effect on the reaction (entry 15). The reaction selectivity was quite sensitive to the reaction time. When it was increased to 8h, the yield of
3a decreased to 32%, and the
N-carboxyethylation product of aniline,
4aa, can be isolated with 38% yield (entry 16). Intriguingly, by decreasing the ratio of
1a/
2a, the reaction selectivity can also be tuned to favoring the formation of
4aa. A 74% of yield can be obtained after 8h in a reaction with equal amount of
1a and
2a under open-air conditions (entry 17). All these observations led us to find conditions B to implement the
N-carboxyethylation of
1a, that are PTSA catalyst, 1, 4-dioxane solvent, a 1.0/1.2 ratio of
1a/
2a, protection with nitrogen balloon, 10h and 80℃. Under these conditions,
4aa can be isolated in 82% yield (entry 20). It should be noted that, in this case, the yield was calculated with respect to the component with lower loading,
1a. Inspired by the observation in performing the reaction in chloroform solvent (entry 11), conditions C for producing
4ba were also identified, which were confirmed to be the followings: PTSA catalyst, chloroform solvent, a 1.0/2.0 ratio of
1a/
2a, protection with nitrogen balloon, 60℃, and 8h (Table S1 in Supporting information for detailed optimization studies). These conditions enabled us to synthesize
4ba in 79% yield (entry 21). In conclusion,
N-(4-bromophenyl)formylation (
3a) was synthesized under condition A:
1a (0.6 mmol),
2a (0.3 mmol) and 20 mol% of PTSA were added in 1, 4-dioxane at 60℃ for 2h under O
2. Methyl phenylglycinate (
4aa) was obtained under condition B:
1a (0.3 mmol),
2a (0.36 mmol) and 20 mol% of PTSA were added in 1, 4-dioxane at 80℃ for 10h under N
2. 2, 2′-(Phenylazanediyl)diacetates (
4ba) was synthesized under condition C:
1a (0.3 mmol),
2a (0.6 mmol) and 20 mol% of PTSA were added in CHCl
3 at 60℃ for 8h under N
2. Having determined the optimized conditions A, B and C, the scope of anilines bearing various functional groups for synthesis of
N-phenylformamides,
N-carboxyethylation and 2, 2′-(phenylazanediyl)diacetates was then explored and the results are summarized in
Scheme 2,
Scheme 3. Upon repeating the reactions of
2a and anilines with different functional groups under the conditions A,
N-phenylformamides
3b–
3v can be synthesized with yields ranging from 43% to 94%.
para-Substituted anilines with a functional group, like methyl (
3c),
tert-butyl (
3d), methoxy (
3e), halogen (
3f and
3g), ethoxycarbonyl (
3h) and trifluoromethyl (
3i), are all tolerated the condition A. However, 4-nitroaniline can hardly be used as substrate, and the expected product,
3k, was formed only in a trace amount.
meta-Substituted anilines are also readily participated in the
N-formylation reaction, giving the expected products
3k–
3o in the yields ranging from 43% to 82%. More sterically demanding
ortho-substituted anilines also engaged successfully in the
N-formylation reaction. Under the conditions A, the reactions of
N-methyl-substituted anilines proceeded also very well, and the expected product,
3t and
3u, were isolated in 78% and 81% yields, respectively. By means of a wise use of an
ortho-substituted aniline, some heterocyclic compounds can be synthesized with slight modification of the condition A. For example,
o-phenylenediamine can be converted to benzimidazole
3w in 63% of yield with the use of 3.0 equiv. of
tert-butyl hydroperoxide (TBHP) as an oxidizing reagent under the conditions A. Anthranilamide can be converted to 4-hydroxyquinazoline
3x in 73% yield under the similar conditions. Literature survey stated that a precedent of transforming anthranilamide to
3y was established based on C-C bond cleavage, however, it involves the use of an expensive reagent, alkynyl ketone, as substrate [
34]. The combination of
2a and TPHP allowed this transformation to be realized by a cost-effective way. Interestingly, a congener of
3x without C-C bond cleavage,
3x', can be obtained in 93% yield under N
2 atmosphere in chloroform solvent. The presence of an acetal fragment adjacent to the nucleophilic aromatic ring may facilitate the downstream conversion of this unique compound.