With the optimal conditions in hand, we evaluated the scope of this reaction (
Scheme 2). Initially, we were pleased to observe that diethyl, dimethyl, di-
n-butyl, diisopropyl and dibenzyl phosphites could lead to corresponding products in 68%-80% yields (
3aa-
3ae). To our delight, the ethyl phenylphosphinate and enthyl methylphosphinate, which have rarely been applied in radical reaction, furnished the desired products (
3af-
3ag, 63%-67%). In contrast, when diphenyl phosphite was investigated, the desired product
3ah could not be isolated. Furthermore, the substituents on the benzene ring in the indole motif including electron-donating groups (Me, OMe), halogens (F, Cl, Br) and electron-withdrawing groups (Ac, CF
3) were also studied (
3ba-
3la, 45%-84%). Besides the electronic effect of various functional groups, the position of the substituents on the benzene ring also has great influence on the reaction outcomes (
3ca,
3fa,
3ga). When two ethyl groups in side-chain were explored instead of two methyl groups, the transformation could lead to the desired product
3ma in moderate yield. In contrast, the diaryl-substituted 3-indolylmethanols
1n proved to be unsuccessful for the reaction which might be due to the too active substrate. Substrates bearing two different groups at the
α-position of hydroxyl were also participated in the relay reaction smoothly and gave the products
3oa (63%),
3pa (36%) and
3pa' (30%) in moderate yields. In addition, the
trans relationship between the methyl and the ethoxy was solved through X-ray crystallographic analysis of compound
3pa'. Intriguingly, secondary alcohol which was applied in lieu of a tertiary one led to 1, 2-oxaphospholoindoles
3qa and
3ra in 60% and 61% yield, respectively, while a lower yield was obtained with a primary alcohol permitted (
3sa, 20%). The low yield for
3w is rationalized by DFT calculations. The predicted ΔG
≠ for the intramolecular nucleophilic cyclization of
INT3b derived from
1w (34.8 kcal/mol) is 7.6 kcal/mol higher than that of
INT3 derived from
1a, suggesting that the formation of
3w is much less favorable than that of
3a (Fig. S2 in Supporting information). Geometrical inspection for
INT3 indicates that the presence of two methyl groups could lead to steric hindrance with C4-H moiety of indole skeleton. Consequently, the rotation of the C3-C1 bond is constrained and the O···P distance in
INT3 is 2.98 Å. However, for
INT3b, such steric hindrance is negligible due to the absence of two methyl groups and therefore the distance of O···P increases to 3.51 Å. Thus, the formation of
3w is not ready to occur and low yield is obtained experimentally. Finally, pyrimidinyl group as protecting group on the indole
N-1 position was also tolerated under the mild reaction condition (
3ta, 73%). Unfortunately,
N-CH
3-3-indolylmethanol and isatin-derived 3-indolylmethanol were not competent substrates (
3ua,
3va).