With this library of water-soluble PNP ligands in hand, we began our studies with an examination of their catalytic performance in Rh-catalyzed branched-selective hydroformylation of styrene
11a as the benchmark substrate. As described in
Table 1, all styrene hydrorformylation reactions were completed in 24 h toluene/H
2O (1:1) solvent at 3.0 MPa of syngas and 60 ℃ in the presence of 0.05 mol% [Rh(COD)Cl]
2 and 0.6 mol% ligand (Rh/
L = 1:6). In all the excellent chemoselectivities were observed, and no hydrogenation product was detected
via 1H NMR analysis. The carbonated PNP ligands
L1-L6 were first examined. The ligands
L1 and
L2 bearing COONa at benzene's
ortho- or
meta-position, gave the branched aldehyde
12a in moderate yields with good regioselectivities (
b/l = 8.5:1 and 8.4:1, entries 1 and 2), respectively. When the ligand
L3 substituted with
meta-OMe and
meta-COONa groups on phenyl ring was employed, poor yield of
12a was obtained, however, the
b/l ratio in this instance was still exceptional (8.4:1, entry 3). Reaction conducted with the ligand
L4 possessing COONa group at
para-position of phenyl ring, delivered branched aldehyde
12a in only 42% yield and with lower regioselectivity (
b/l = 6.5:1, entry 4). The dicarboxylated PNP ligand
L5 gave better yield (75%, entry 5) compared with results of monocarboxylated PNP ligands (
L1-L4), but with poor regioselectivity (
b/l = 3.0:1). Moreover, the monocarboxylated PNP ligand
L6 with a biphenyl ring resulted in much higher yield (84%), albeit with a ratio of
12a/
13a of 5.4:1 (entry 6). The sulfonated PNP ligand
L7 with
meta-SO
3Na gave poor yield and regioselectivity (26%,
b/l = 3.8:1, entry 7) under identical conditions. The ligand
L8 bearing
meta-SO
3Na and
para-MeO groups of phenyl ring was shown to give superior yield of
12a, but much worse regioselectivity (
12a/
13a = 3.2:1) was obtained (entry 8). A change of the position of SO
3Na group on ligand
L7 from
meta- to
para-position resulted in similar yield (entry 9), but high regioselectivity compared with the results of the corresponding sulfonated PNP ligand
L7-L10. The use of ligand
L11 with
ortho-SO
3Na group on phenyl ring afforded branched aldehyde
12a in 92% yield with high regioselectivity (
b/
l = 11.3:1, entry 11). The well-known TPPTS only gave 74% yield of
12a, with poor regioselectivity (
b/
l = 2.8:1, entry 12) under identical conditions. Other common Rh catalysts for hydroformylation, such as Rh(acac)(CO)
2) and RhCl
3, low regioselectivities and reactivities were respectively obtained (entries 13 and 14). Addition of SDBS (0.86 mol%) as the surfactant could short reaction time to 12 h, and provide branched
12a in 91% yield and a 10.1:1 ratio of
b/l (entry 15). Branched product was obtained in 72% yield with 10.0:1 ratio of
b/l in absence of SDBS (
Table 1, entry 16). The control experiment of absence of ligand was also carried out to give the product in 74% yield with 2.8:1 ratio
b/l (entry 17). These results revealed the crucial role of these two types of ligand structures in controlling of yield and regioselectivity for this Rh-catalyzed hydroformylation reaction.