The
in vitro gene transfection activity of the isolated HPAEs and HPAE-Cr was evaluated in HeLa, HepG2, and HaCaT cells at HPAE/DNA w/w ratios of 10:1, 30:1 and 50:1, according to previous studies [
25-
30]. Plasmids encoding cytoplasmic green fluorescent protein (GFP) or secreted Gaussia luciferase (Gluc) were used as reporter genes. As shown in
Fig. 3 and Fig. S16 (Supporting information), in general HPAE-33.1 k, HPAE-48.6 k, and HPAE-68.6 k, components with medium or high MW, generally show significantly stronger gene transfection activity in HeLa cells than the low MW counterpart HPAE-5.3 k, regardless of the w/w ratios used, as seen by the higher number of GFP positive cells in the fluorescence images. In particular, HPAE-33.1 k exhibits the strongest gene transfection activity, rivaling even the leading commercial gene transfection reagent jetPEI, especially at the lowest w/w ratio of 10:1. Compared to HPAE-Cr, isolated HPAE-33.1 k and HPAE-48.6 k also exhibit higher or comparable gene transfection activity at all three w/w ratios. The gene transfection efficiency of HPAEs with different MW was further quantified by measuring the Gluc activity of the cells after transfection, and a trend similar to that observed for GFP expression was observed. As shown in
Fig. 4, the Gluc activity of HeLa cells after transfection with HPAE-33.1 k, HPAE-48.6 k and HPAE-68.6 k was up to two orders of magnitude higher than that mediated by HPAE-5.3 k. At a 10:1 w/w ratio, the Gluc activity of HeLa cells after transfection with HPAE-33.1 k was 70- and 1.1-fold higher than that mediated by HPAE-5.3 k and HPAE-Cr, respectively. Importantly, alarmarBlue assays clearly show that all isolated HPAEs retain relatively high cell viability after transfection, especially at the 10:1 and 30:1 w/w ratios. In contrast, HPAE-Cr mediates a similar level of gene transfection activity as HPAE-33.1 k, HPAE-48.6 k, and HPAE-68.6 k, but the cell viability at the 30:1 w/w was only about 60%. Although, jetPEI has the strongest gene transfection activity, cell viability after transfection was only about 40%, much lower than the viability mediated by HPAEs, even when the highest w/w ratio of 50:1 was used. In HepG2 cells, HPAE-33.1 k, HPAE-48.6 k, and HPAE-68.6 k surprisingly show much stronger transfection activity than HPAE-5.3 k and HPAE-Cr, especially at the w/w ratios of 30:1 and 50:1 (Fig. S17 in Supporting information). In a good correlation with GFP expression, the Gluc activity of cells after transfection by HPAE-33.1 k, HPAE-48.6 k, and HPAE-68.6 k is up to 100- and 4-fold higher than that mediated by HPAE-5.3 k and HPAE-Cr, respectively. At the same time, relatively higher cell viability was maintained, especially at the 10:1 and 30:1 w/w ratios (Fig. S18 in Supporting information). The low MW HPAE-5.3 k exhibited higher cytotoxicity, which may be due to the polyplexes being more aggregated and therefore adsorbing more readily to the cell membrane, leading to excessive interactions of the polyplexes with the lipid bilayer of the cells and causing higher cytotoxicity [
26]. As for the difficult-to-transfect HaCaT cells, HPAEs with intermediate and high MW also showed stronger and comparable gene transfection activity compared with HPAE-5.3 k and HPAE-Cr (Figs. S19 and S20 in Supporting information). All these results indicate that MW has a significant effect on the gene transfection performance of HPAEs. In general, HPAEs with medium and high MW (
e.g., 33.1 k, 48.6 k and 68.6 k) exhibit much stronger gene transfection activity than the low MW analog (
e.g., 5.3 k). The fact that HPAE-5.3 k mediates low gene transfection activity, whereas HPAE-48.6 k and HPAE-68.6 k elicit relatively high cytotoxicity in certain cell types, underscores that HPAE with an intermediate MW (
i.e., 33.1 k) is the most potent candidate among HPAEs for gene delivery in achieving high gene transfection efficiency and cell viability simultaneously. From this perspective, isolation of intermediate MW components from HPAE-Cr by fractionation is of great clinical importance.