In order to further confirm the catalytic property of
1, a series of controlling reactions were conducted. In the absence of catalyst, 59.4% aniline is converted in 24 h (
Table 1, entry 3), much lower than that with 0.75 mol%
1 (99.4%,
Table 1, entry 1), suggesting the effectiveness of the catalyst. The performances of Na
3PW
12O
40 and TBA
3PW
12O
40 were also evaluated. The saturated polyanion [PW
12O
40] gives good conversion of aniline, but the selectivity to AOB is much lower than that with
1 (
Table 1, entries 4 and 5). When the reaction time with
1 is shortened to 12 h, 85.4% aniline is converted (
Table 1, entry 6). However, the selectivity to AOB is nearly invariable, suggesting the condensation step is not the rate-determining step of the reaction. Further shortened reaction times such as 2 h, 1 h, and 0.5 h cause dramatic decrease of aniline conversion, but moderate to good selectivity to AOB are obtained (
Table 1, entries 7–9). Compound
2 shows comparative performance with
1 (
Table 1, entry 10). The precursor of
1 and
2, Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O, gives 99.2% conversion of aniline, but the selectivity to AOB is only 60.5%, while the amount of NSB dramatically increases to 26.1% (
Table 1, entry 11), being indicative of the fast production of NSB or the suppression of the condensation step probably caused by the relative alkalinity of the trilacunary polyanion. We have also attempted to insight the reaction pattern with Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O by shortening the reaction time (
Table 1, entries 12–14). Surprisingly, a relatively high aniline conversion of 78.3% is obtained in 0.5 h, and then slowly increases to 99.2% in 24 h. The selectivity to NSB decreases to 26.1% from 66.9%, and that to AOB contrarily increases to 60.5% from 26.0% with the prolonged reaction time. The results are apparently different from that with
1 as the catalyst. It is clear that in the reaction with Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O, the condensation of NSB to AOB is the rate-determining step of the reaction. Apparently, the introduction of {Ni
6} cluster into the skeleton of Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O successfully changes the catalytic behavior of Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O (
Scheme 2). Besides, NiCl
2·6H
2O shows negligible catalytic performance (
Table 1, entry 15). When the mixture of Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O and NiCl
2·6H
2O is used as the catalyst, 82.7% aniline is converted and the selectivity to AOB is 92.3% (
Table 1, entry 16). The conversion is lower than that with pure Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O. However, the selectivity to AOB with the mixture is much higher than that with pure Na
9PW
9O
34·nH
2O (60.5%), revealing that the presence of Ni
2+ may slight depress the oxidation of aniline to NSB, but significantly promote the condensation of NSB to AOB. Prolonged reaction time and adjusted dosage of Ni
2+ do not improve the conversion of aniline with the mixture (Table S7 in Supporting information). Based on these results, it is inferred that in the reactions with
1 and
2, the elements W and Ni work cooperatively to guarantee the selective oxidation of aniline to AOB. The effect of {Ni
6} on the reaction results can be explained from two aspects. On one hand, the {Ni
6} cluster accelerates the condensation of NSB with PHA; on the other hand, the introduction of {Ni
6} cluster may essentially change the electron structure of the matrix {PW
9} and resultantly lead to the change of its redox property [
38,
39]. The point is also confirmed by the broadened UV–vis absorbance at 259 nm of compound
1, which is ascribed to the O
2p→W
5d charge transfer, a common feature in all polyoxotungstates (Fig. S9 in Supporting information).