To investigate the NITRR performance of the Co
4N/NF electrocatalyst, an H-type electrolytic cell containing 0.5 mol/L K
2SO
4 and 200 ppm NO
3--N was used. Co
4N/NF, platinum gauze, and saturated Ag/AgCl electrode were used as the working, counter, and reference electrodes, respectively. For convenience of comparison, all potentials reported in this work were converted to the RHE according to the following formula,
E(
vs. RHE) =
E(
vs. Ag/AgCl) + 0.059 × pH + 0.197. The electrochemical nitrate reduction was tested at various potentials ranging from −0.29 V to −0.59 V
vs. RHE. The reactant and products including NO
3-, NH
3 and NO
2- were detected by colorimetric methods, and the corresponding ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) adsorption spectra with concentration-absorbance calibration curves are plotted in Figs. S3-S5 (Supporting information).
Fig. 2a shows the linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) curves of different electrodes (NF, Co(OH)F/NF, Co
4N/NF) with (solid line) and without (dash line) NO
3- at a scan rate of 5 mV/s. The blank NF performs relatively low current density both in the presence and absence of NO
3-, proving that it has almost no NITRR activity and HER activity at low overpotential. The current density of Co(OH)F/NF shows no significant increase in 0.5 mol/L K
2SO
4 electrolyte with 200 ppm NO
3--N, indicating its poor NITRR activity. Compared with the substrate and the precursor, the significantly increased current density of Co
4N/NF in the electrolyte with nitrate compared to without nitrate at the same overpotential, implying the superior catalytic activity of Co
4N/NF toward NITRR. The reduction peak in the figure may be the reduction peak of Co unrelated to nitrate reduction, as it appears on the LSV curve in blank K
2SO
4 electrolyte. This peak disappears in the presence of NO
3-, possibly due to the large current density response of Co
4N to nitrate reduction, covering the peak. To further investigate the catalytic performance of Co
4N/NF, chronoamperometry (CA) tests were performed at various potentials (−0.29 ~ −0.59 V
vs. RHE). As shown in
Fig. 2b and Fig. S6 (Supporting information), with the decrease of cathodic potential, the Faradaic efficiency and selectivity of ammonia display a volcanic shape curve while the NH
3 yield rate gradually increases and tends to be stable. The change trend of NO
3- conversion rate is similar to that of NH
3 yield rate. The Faradaic efficiency and selectivity of ammonia reached their respective maximum at −0.44 V
vs. RHE, so it was determined as the optimal potential. At −0.44 V
vs. RHE, the Faradaic efficiency, NH
3 yield rate, conversion rate of NO
3-, and NH
3 selectivity of Co
4N/NF are 95.4%, 0.2475 mmol h
−1 cm
−2, 89.5%, and 99.4%, respectively. The yield rate of NH
3 is much higher than that of Co(OH)F/NF (0.0169 mmol h
−1 cm
−2) and NF (0.0041 mmol h
−1 cm
−2) (Fig. S7 in Supporting information), demonstrating that Co
4N/NF catalyzes the conversion of NO
3- to NH
3 effectively. The Faraday efficiency and selectivity of Co
4N/NF are superior to or comparable to most other reported NITRR catalysts or vacancy engineering related catalysts (Tables S1 and S2 in Supporting information). The time-dependent concentration curves of NO
3-, NH
3 and NO
2- were recorded at −0.44 V
vs. RHE. With the extension of reduction time, the concentration of NO
3- gradually decreases, and the concentration of NH
3 displays a completely opposite trend, indicating that ammonia is produced by the reduction of nitrate (
Fig. 2c). Meanwhile, the concentration of NO
2- is extremely low throughout the reaction process, suggesting that the production of NO
2- as a byproduct is suppressed, which improves the selectivity of NH
3. As illustrated in Figs. S8 and S9 (Supporting information) and
Fig. 2d, we also performed the consecutive recycling tests at −0.44 V
vs. RHE to evaluate the durability of the prepared catalyst. Fig. S8 shows the chronoamperometric curves, the current density recovers immediately when the electrolyte is refreshed. After seven consecutive cycles, the Faradaic efficiency, NH
3 yield rate, conversion rate of NO
3-, and NH
3 selectivity can remain stable, proving the outstanding stability of Co
4N/NF under neutral condition (
Fig. 2d and Fig. S9). We also investigated the effect of some ions (CO
32-, Na
+, Cl
-, ClO
4-, HCO
3-, Li
+) commonly found in actual nitrate wastewater on the NITRR activity of Co
4N/NF. As shown in Figs. S10 and S11 (Supporting information), our catalyst can still maintain high NITRR activity when these ions coexist. In order to eliminate external interference, the ammonia yield of Co
4N/NF was determined after electroreduction in a nitrate-free blank electrolyte. As shown in
Fig. 2e, no ammonia can be detected in the absence of NO
3-, indicating that the detected ammonia originates from the added nitrate. We also conducted isotope labeling experiments to strengthen the result described above [
20–
22]. As shown in
Fig. 2f, when the reactant is K
14NO
3, the
1H NMR spectra show representative triple peaks of
14NH
4+, while typical double peaks of
15NH
4+ can be detected if the reactant is replaced by K
15NO
3 [
23,
24]. No significant
14NH
4+ can be observed when K
15NO
3 is used, confirming that the produced ammonia is completely evolved from the electrochemical reduction of NO
3- rather than external interference.