With
15 in hand, the subsequent construction of caged F ring was investigated. We first screened reduction conditions for the formation of
β‑hydroxy ester (
Table 1). In the presence of NaBH
4 (
Table 1, entry 1), a pair of diastereomers
6a (desired, 24% yield) and
6b (57% yield) were mainly obtained with trace amount of
6c. The relative configurations of
6a-
6c were elucidated separately through demethoy-
6a (CCDC 2255376), demethoxy-
6b derivative (CCDC 2255374) and demethoy-
6c (CCDC 2255375) by X-ray crystallographic analysis. Since the stereochemistry of the carbon chiral center adjacent to ester functionality is essential for the following reductive cyclization to assemble the caged ring, more productive condition was needed. When NaBH
4 reduction with NH
4Cl as buffering reagent [
35-
37] was carried out, the diastereoselectivity did not increase (
Table 1, entry 2). An attempted addition of metal salt such as MgCl
2 as chelating reagent [
38] did not improve the selectivity (
Table 1, entry 3). When Me
4NBH(OAc)
3 [
39] was used as reductant, no reaction occurred and
15 was recovered (
Table 1, entry 4).
nBu
4NBH
4 reduction [
40] also did not give better result (
Table 1, entry 5). When the reaction was perfomed in the presence of bulky reductants such as l-selectride [
41-
43] and LiAl(O
tBu)
3H [
44], the reactions were complicated, and only undesired
6b was obtained (
Table 1, entries 6 and 7). Ru-catalyzed transfer hydrogenation (
Table 1, entry 8) [
45-
49] and Crabtree's catalyst (
Table 1, entry 9) [
50,
51] failed to give the desired
β‑hydroxy ester. After much experimentation on selective hydride reduction, an acceptable and reliable hydrogenation reaction condition was found. Hydrogenation of the
β-keto ester
15 using H
2 over PtO
2 under mild condition allowed the generation of two diastereomers
α‑hydroxy esters
6a in 46% yield and
6b in 42% yield (
Table 1, entry 10) [
52,
53]. One of the resulting diastereomer
6b can be further transferred to
6a through hydroxy oxidation and ketone reduction, which implied that
β-keto ester
15 underwent enolization when the hydrogenation occurred. We also conducted an extensive evaluation of reaction conditions to promote epimerization of
6b to the desired stereo-configuration by the enolization/kinetic protonation sequence. Despite screening for bases, reaction times, and temperatures, we were unable to achieve the epimerization of
6b. In almost all cases,
6b was recovered, and no other products were generated. By treating
6b with KHMDS and then quenching with D
2O, it was found by NMR that the
α-H of the ester group was partially deuterated. We assumed that the enolization of the ester could occur under the reaction condition, but the proton was still subsequently attacked from the side with relatively small steric hindrance, affording configuration-preserving starting materials. The failure of enolization of
6b under strongly basic conditions by the kinetic protonation prompted us to evaluate thermodynamic conditions for the epimerization. A wide range of bases were examined, such as DBU,
tBuOK and NaOEt, however all conditions lead to decomposition or unreacted starting material. Since
6b can be transferred to
6a, the condition using H
2 over PtO
2 (
Table 1, entry 10) was applied to synthesize
6a. Reductive cyclization of
6a with LAH afforded cage-like skeleton
16 in 76% yield [
54,
55]. As a result, the crucial caged F ring was successfully formed
via ester reduction/amide semireduction/cyclization sequence. We also investigated reduction of
15 with LAH to get
16 via ketone reduction/ester reduction/amide semireduction/cyclization sequence directly, however complex reaction mixture was obtained along with 10% yield of desired
16. Since the stereochemistry of the carbon chiral center adjacent to hydroxy functionality of
16 was opposite to the natural product, we planned to invert the stereochemistry by DMP oxidation and NaBH
4 reduction. The expected epimerization occurred and afforded
17 in 73% yield over two steps. The total synthesis was wrapped up with desilylation of TES group with TBAF, and thereby (+)-tabernabovine B (
2) was obtained in 98% yield. The
1H and
13C NMR data of synthetic
2 was in agreement with those reported for natural product (+)-tabernabovine B.