As previously mentioned, nanoribbon-assembled hierarchical porous structure, and Mn-incorporation induced electronic structure regulation render Mn-VN cardoon a promising robust electrocatalyst, which was further verified by experiments. The electrocatalytic performances of Mn-VN, Bulk-Mn-VN, pure VN, and Pt/C catalysts toward HER were evaluated in 1 mol/L KOH using a typical three-electrode system.
Fig. 4a displays the polarization curves obtained by linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) test after 95% iR compensation. Mn-VN cardoon can achieve current densities of 10, 50, and 100 mA/cm
2 with low overpotentials of only 86, 159, and 191 mV, much lower than those of Bulk-Mn-VN (178, 256, and 293 mV) and VN (226, 305, and 355 mV), respectively. Noticeably, the activity of Mn-VN is better than that of Pt/C, when current density exceeds 260 mA/cm
2.
Fig. 4b visually compares the overpotentials of various electrodes, in which the same potential trend as above can be observed at higher current densities (Table S2 in Supporting information), indicating the Mn-VN presents a significantly enhanced HER activity compared to Bulk-Mn-VN and VN. Moreover, the electrocatalytic HER performance of the Mn-VN cardoon surpasses that of most VN-based materials (Table S3 in Supporting information). To elucidate the electrocatalytic kinetic mechanism, Tafel slope was analyzed by fitting the linear segment of the Tafel plot. As presented in
Fig. 4c, the Mn-VN cardoon possesses a Tafel slope of 58 mV/dec, which is much lower than that of Bulk-Mn-VN (124 mV/dec) and VN (135 mV/dec), indicating its faster electrode reaction kinetics. The HER kinetic mechanism of the Mn-VN cardoon follows the Volmer−Heyrovsky mechanism, where electrochemical desorption is identified as the rate-limiting step [
5]. Compared with VN, the significantly reduced Tafel slope indicates that the sluggish Volmer step of VN is greatly accelerated after Mn incorporation, highlighting the advantage of Mn incorporation. The exchange current density (
j0) of Mn-VN cardoon is determined to be 0.741 mA/cm
2, much higher than that of Bulk-Mn-VN (0.414 mA/cm
2) and VN catalysts (0.325 mA/cm
2), revealing the higher excellent kinetics characteristics of Mn-VN toward HER (Fig. S13 in Supporting information). Such remarkable enhanced activity of Mn-VN cardoon is closely related to its inherent characteristics. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) tests (
Fig. 4d) reveal that Mn-VN cardoon delivers a low charge transfer resistance (
Rct) of about 4.5 Ω, much lower than the reference samples, Bulk-Mn-VN (≈7.5 Ω) and VN (≈12.0 Ω), suggesting that Mn-VN cardoon possesses faster charge transfer with reactants/intermediates during the HER. Interestingly, both Mn-VN cardoon and Bulk-Mn-VN show lower
Rct compared to VN, implying that Mn incorporation in VN significantly improves electrical conductivity by adjusting the electronic structure. The catalytic activity strongly depends on the number of the exposed active sites and the inherent activity [
29]. Therefore, the electrochemical active surface area (ECSA) was further determined by measuring double-layer capacitance (
Cdl) (
Fig. 4e and Fig. S14 in Supporting information), which can evaluate the number of accessible active sites. The order of
Cdl values for different catalysts is Mn-VN cardoon (208.3 mF/cm
2) > Bulk-Mn-VN (118.7 mF/cm
2) > VN (31.4 mF/cm
2). As
Cdl value is directly proportional to ECSA, the Mn-VN cardoon has the largest ECSA (Fig. S15a in Supporting information), which is approximately 6.6 and 1.8 times that of VN and Bulk-Mn-VN, respectively, suggesting that Mn-VN could expose more active sites during HER. The above implies that both Mn incorporation and morphology engineering play important roles in creating/exposing more active sites, and thus improving HER performance. What is more, through careful comparison, the incorporation of Mn in the VN lattice appeared to have even far more impact than morphology engineering in increasing active sites. Furthermore, the ECSA-normalized LSV curves (Fig. S15b in Supporting information) indicate that the Mn-VN cardoon catalyst exhibits a higher
jECSA than the others at the same potential, suggesting higher intrinsic activity of the individual active site in Mn-VN cardoon, which benefits greatly from morphology tailoring and electronic structure regulation by Mn incorporation [
36]. The superiority of Mn incorporated VN for HER were further confirmed by density functional theory (DFT) calculations (Fig. S16 in Supporting information). Long-term stability is another key criterion to evaluate whether the electrocatalytic performance of catalysts is suitable for practical applications. As displayed in
Fig. 4f, the polarization curve of Mn-VN cardoon after 3000 CV cycles is nearly identical to the initial one. The chronoamperometric test shows that a slightly decay in current density emerged after 100 h operation. Moreover, multi-step chronoamperometric curves of Mn-VN under various current density display each step remains nearly no notice change (
Fig. 4g), indicating a predominant mechanical robustness [
48]. These results verify the excellent electrochemical stability of Mn-VN cardoon for HER catalysis. Moreover, XRD, SEM, TEM images, and XPS spectra (Figs. S17 and S18 in Supporting information) demonstrate that the crystal structure, morphology and chemical state of Mn-VN are well maintained after durability test. The dependence of HER activity on [MnV
13] amount and calcination temperature were also investigated (Figs. S19 and S20 in Supporting information). The above results strongly confirm that the significant influence of hierarchical structured morphology and electron structure regulation induced by Mn incorporation on the catalytic activity.