药学学报

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Quercetin	Nicotinamide		●■	[2]
	Betaine		●■	[3]
	Theophylline		●■	[3]
	L-Proline		●■	[3]
	Pentoxifylline		●■	[3]
	Apixaban	O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[4]
	Pyrazol			[5]
	Imidazolidinone			[5]
	Baclofen			[5]
	N-Acetylcytosine		■	[5]
	Carnitine		■	[5]
	Kojic acid		■	[5]
	Isoniazid		●■	[6]
Luteolin	L-Proline	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O	■	[7]
	Piperazine		▲	[8]
	Isoniazid	C-H···N, N-H···N	▲●	[9]
	Caffeine		▲●■	[9]
	Lysine		▲●	[10]
	Arginine		▲●	[10]
	Isonicotinamide			[11]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine		■	[12]
Chrysin	Piperazine		●	[13]
	Ethionamide	O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O N-H···O, N-H···S		[13]
	Berberine hydrochloride		■	[14]
	Cytosine	π-π, C-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[15]
	Thiamine hydrochloride	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, N-H···Cl	●	[15]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[16]
	1, 4-Bis(pyridin-4-ylmethoxy) benzene	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[16]
Kaempferol	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[17]
	Piperazine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O N-H···O, N-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Tetramethylprazine	C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Pyrazinamide	π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O N-H···O, O-H···O	▲●	[13]
	Palbociclib	O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O	▲●■	[18]
	5-Fluorouracil		●■	[19]
Myricetin	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	■	[20]
	Nicotinamide		●	[21]
	Isonicotinamide		●	[21]
	4-Cyanopyridine		●	[21]
	Caffeine	O-H···O, O-H···N	●	[22]
	Proline	O-H···O, C-O···N	●■	[23]
	Tetramethylprazine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	●	[13]
	Tegafur		▲●	[24]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
Dihydromyricetin	Theophylline	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N O-H···N, O-H···O=C	▲●	[26]
	Benzamide	N-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···O		[26]
	Caffeine	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N O-H···N, O-H···O=C	●	[26]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Pentoxifylline		●■	[27]
Apigenin	Theophylline	O-H···N	●■	[28]
	Nicotinamide		●	[29]
	Piperazine		●■	[30]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[31]
Daidzeine	Piracetam		●	[32]
	L-Proline		●	[33]
	Lornoxicam		▲●	[34]
	L-Pyroglutamic acid		●	[35]
Baicalein	Theophylline	O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N	●■	[36]
	Caffeine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[37]
	Nicotinamide	O-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···C=O N-H···C=O	●■	[38]
Fisetin	Isonicotinamide	C-H···O, N-H···O	●	[39]
	Nicotinamide/ hemiethanolate (1∶2)	N-H···O, O-H···O, O-C···N	●	[39]
	Nicotinamide		●	[39]
	Caffeine		●	[39]
Genistein	Proline		▼◆	[7]
	Nicotinamide			[11]
	Caffeine	π-π, C-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···O	▲●	[40]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[41]
	Tetramethylpyrazine	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲●■	[42]
Naringenin	Isonicotinamide	π-π, O-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O=C	●■	[43]
	Picolinic acid		●	[43]
	Betaine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···O=C	●	[43]
	Flavone	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···O=C	●	[44]
	4-Hydroxypyridine	O-H···O, N-H···O	●	[44]
	Anthranilamide	O-H··N, O-H···O, N-H··O	●	[44]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H··N, C-H···O		[44]
Hesperetin	Picolinic acid		●■	[45]
	Nicotinamide	N-H···N, O-H···N O-H···O=C, O-H···N	●■	[45]
	Caffeine	O-H···N, O-H···O=C	●	[45]
	Temozolomide	O-H···O, N-H··O	●■	[46]
Daidzein	Theophylline		▲●■	[28]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H∙∙∙N, C-H∙∙∙O	●	[47]
Isoliquiritigenin	Nicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O C-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[48]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O	●■	[48]
Phloretin	Nicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O, C-H···O	●	[49]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	●	[49]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Quercetin	Nicotinamide		●■	[2]
	Betaine		●■	[3]
	Theophylline		●■	[3]
	L-Proline		●■	[3]
	Pentoxifylline		●■	[3]
	Apixaban	O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[4]
	Pyrazol			[5]
	Imidazolidinone			[5]
	Baclofen			[5]
	N-Acetylcytosine		■	[5]
	Carnitine		■	[5]
	Kojic acid		■	[5]
	Isoniazid		●■	[6]
Luteolin	L-Proline	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O	■	[7]
	Piperazine		▲	[8]
	Isoniazid	C-H···N, N-H···N	▲●	[9]
	Caffeine		▲●■	[9]
	Lysine		▲●	[10]
	Arginine		▲●	[10]
	Isonicotinamide			[11]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine		■	[12]
Chrysin	Piperazine		●	[13]
	Ethionamide	O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O N-H···O, N-H···S		[13]
	Berberine hydrochloride		■	[14]
	Cytosine	π-π, C-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[15]
	Thiamine hydrochloride	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, N-H···Cl	●	[15]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[16]
	1, 4-Bis(pyridin-4-ylmethoxy) benzene	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[16]
Kaempferol	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[17]
	Piperazine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O N-H···O, N-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Tetramethylprazine	C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Pyrazinamide	π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O N-H···O, O-H···O	▲●	[13]
	Palbociclib	O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O	▲●■	[18]
	5-Fluorouracil		●■	[19]
Myricetin	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	■	[20]
	Nicotinamide		●	[21]
	Isonicotinamide		●	[21]
	4-Cyanopyridine		●	[21]
	Caffeine	O-H···O, O-H···N	●	[22]
	Proline	O-H···O, C-O···N	●■	[23]
	Tetramethylprazine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	●	[13]
	Tegafur		▲●	[24]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
Dihydromyricetin	Theophylline	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N O-H···N, O-H···O=C	▲●	[26]
	Benzamide	N-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···O		[26]
	Caffeine	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N O-H···N, O-H···O=C	●	[26]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Pentoxifylline		●■	[27]
Apigenin	Theophylline	O-H···N	●■	[28]
	Nicotinamide		●	[29]
	Piperazine		●■	[30]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[31]
Daidzeine	Piracetam		●	[32]
	L-Proline		●	[33]
	Lornoxicam		▲●	[34]
	L-Pyroglutamic acid		●	[35]
Baicalein	Theophylline	O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N	●■	[36]
	Caffeine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[37]
	Nicotinamide	O-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···C=O N-H···C=O	●■	[38]
Fisetin	Isonicotinamide	C-H···O, N-H···O	●	[39]
	Nicotinamide/ hemiethanolate (1∶2)	N-H···O, O-H···O, O-C···N	●	[39]
	Nicotinamide		●	[39]
	Caffeine		●	[39]
Genistein	Proline		▼◆	[7]
	Nicotinamide			[11]
	Caffeine	π-π, C-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···O	▲●	[40]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[41]
	Tetramethylpyrazine	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲●■	[42]
Naringenin	Isonicotinamide	π-π, O-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O=C	●■	[43]
	Picolinic acid		●	[43]
	Betaine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···O=C	●	[43]
	Flavone	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···O=C	●	[44]
	4-Hydroxypyridine	O-H···O, N-H···O	●	[44]
	Anthranilamide	O-H··N, O-H···O, N-H··O	●	[44]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H··N, C-H···O		[44]
Hesperetin	Picolinic acid		●■	[45]
	Nicotinamide	N-H···N, O-H···N O-H···O=C, O-H···N	●■	[45]
	Caffeine	O-H···N, O-H···O=C	●	[45]
	Temozolomide	O-H···O, N-H··O	●■	[46]
Daidzein	Theophylline		▲●■	[28]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H∙∙∙N, C-H∙∙∙O	●	[47]
Isoliquiritigenin	Nicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O C-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[48]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O	●■	[48]
Phloretin	Nicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O, C-H···O	●	[49]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	●	[49]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Berberine hydrochloride	Chrysin		●■	[14]
	Myricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Dihydromyricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Citric acid		●	[50]
	Lactic acid		●	[50]
	L(+)-Lactic acid hydrate		▲●	[51]
	Fumaric acid	π-π, O-H···Cl	▲●	[52]
	Emodin		●■	[53]
Berberine	Rosiglitazone		■	[54]
	Ibuprofen		●■	[55]
Theophylline	Apigenin	O-H···N		[28]
	Daidzein		▲●■	[28]
	Baicalein	O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O		[36]
	Acetaminophen			[56]
	(Phenylthio) acetic acid	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O	■	[57]
	Ferulic acid		▲◆	[58]
Caffeine	Myricetin	O-H···O, O-H···N		[20]
	Dihydromyricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N, O-H···N, O-H···O=C		[26]
	Baicalein	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[37]
	Oxalic acid		▲	[59]
	Furosemide			[60]
Tetramethylpyrazine	3-Iodoacetylbenzoic acid			[61]
	Kaempferol	C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Myricetin	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Genistein	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲	[42]
	Bexarotene	C-H···N		[62]
Theobromine	P-Coumaric	O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···O	▲	[63]
	2, 4, 6-Trihydroxybenzoic acid monohydrate	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O	▲	[63]
	Gallic acid monohydrate	O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	▲	[63]
	Citric acid monohydrate		▲	[63]
	1-Hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid		◆	[63]
Tetrahydroberberine	Phosphomolybdic acid		■	[64]
	Silicotungstic acid		■	[64]
	Phosphotungstic acid		■	[64]
	L-Aspartic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Gallic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Oxalic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Malonate		▲●■	[64]
	Maleic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Fumaric acid		▲●■	[64]
Tetrahydropalmatine	Camphorsulfonic acid		●■	[65]
	Sulfosalicylic acid		●■	[65]
	P-Aminobenzene sulfonic acid		●■	[65]
	Maleic acid		●	[65]
	Fumaric acid		●	[65]
	Methanesulfonic acid		●	[65]
	Sulfamic acid		●	[65]
Matrine	Fe (Ⅲ)		▲■	[66]
	Rhein			[67]
Nicotine	Tartaric acid			[68]
	Malate			[69]
	3, 5-Dinitrosalicylic acid			[70]
	5-Sulfosalicylic acid salt			[70]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Berberine hydrochloride	Chrysin		●■	[14]
	Myricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Dihydromyricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Citric acid		●	[50]
	Lactic acid		●	[50]
	L(+)-Lactic acid hydrate		▲●	[51]
	Fumaric acid	π-π, O-H···Cl	▲●	[52]
	Emodin		●■	[53]
Berberine	Rosiglitazone		■	[54]
	Ibuprofen		●■	[55]
Theophylline	Apigenin	O-H···N		[28]
	Daidzein		▲●■	[28]
	Baicalein	O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O		[36]
	Acetaminophen			[56]
	(Phenylthio) acetic acid	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O	■	[57]
	Ferulic acid		▲◆	[58]
Caffeine	Myricetin	O-H···O, O-H···N		[20]
	Dihydromyricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N, O-H···N, O-H···O=C		[26]
	Baicalein	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[37]
	Oxalic acid		▲	[59]
	Furosemide			[60]
Tetramethylpyrazine	3-Iodoacetylbenzoic acid			[61]
	Kaempferol	C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Myricetin	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Genistein	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲	[42]
	Bexarotene	C-H···N		[62]
Theobromine	P-Coumaric	O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···O	▲	[63]
	2, 4, 6-Trihydroxybenzoic acid monohydrate	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O	▲	[63]
	Gallic acid monohydrate	O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	▲	[63]
	Citric acid monohydrate		▲	[63]
	1-Hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid		◆	[63]
Tetrahydroberberine	Phosphomolybdic acid		■	[64]
	Silicotungstic acid		■	[64]
	Phosphotungstic acid		■	[64]
	L-Aspartic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Gallic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Oxalic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Malonate		▲●■	[64]
	Maleic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Fumaric acid		▲●■	[64]
Tetrahydropalmatine	Camphorsulfonic acid		●■	[65]
	Sulfosalicylic acid		●■	[65]
	P-Aminobenzene sulfonic acid		●■	[65]
	Maleic acid		●	[65]
	Fumaric acid		●	[65]
	Methanesulfonic acid		●	[65]
	Sulfamic acid		●	[65]
Matrine	Fe (Ⅲ)		▲■	[66]
	Rhein			[67]
Nicotine	Tartaric acid			[68]
	Malate			[69]
	3, 5-Dinitrosalicylic acid			[70]
	5-Sulfosalicylic acid salt			[70]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Resveratrol	Phenazine	C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N		[71]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H···N		[71]
	Piperazine	O-H···O, O-H···N	●	[71]
	1, 10-Phenanthroline	C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N
	1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane			[71]
	Methenamine	O-H···N	●	[71]
	Acridine	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N		[71]
	Succinimide	O-H···O, N-H··O, C-H···O		[71]
	N, N-Dimethyl-4-aminopyridine	O-H···O, O-H··N		[71]
	4-Aminobenzamide		▲●	[72]
	Isoniazid		▲●	[72]
	Amantadine hydrochloride	C-H···Cl, N-H···Cl, O-H···Cl, N-H···O	●■	[73]
	Curcumin		●■	[74]
Bergenin	P-Aminobenzamide	O-H···O, N-H···O	▲●	[58]
	Isonicotinamide	O-H···O, N-H···O	▲●	[58]
	Proline		●	[75]
Oxyresveratrol	Betaine		●	[41]
	L-Proline		●	[41]
	Isonicotinamide		●	[41]
	Nicotinamide		●	[41]
	Urea		●	[41]
	Ethyl maltol		●	[41]
Curcumin	Resveratrol		●■	[74]
	N-Acetylcysteine		●	[76]
	Nicotinamide		●■	[77]
	Ascorbic acid		●	[78]
	Trimellitic anhydride		●■	[79]
	Hydroxyquinolones		■	[79]
Gallic acid	4-Cyanopyridine	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O、O-H···O, N-H···O	●■	[80]
	2, 6-Bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]cyclohexanone	O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[81]
	N-Methyl-3, 5-bis((pyridin-3-yl)methylene)-4-piperidone	O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[81]
	N-Methyl-3, 5-bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]-4-piperidone	O-H···N, O-H···O	■	[81]
	P-Aminobenzoic acid		●■	[82]
	Succinimide		●■	[82]
	Aminoacetic acid		●★	[82]
	L-Proline		●■	[82]
	Glutaric acid		●■	[82]
	Piperazine		■	[82]
	Caffeine		■	[82]
Paeonol	Carbamazepine	O-H···N, O-H···O	●	[83]
Pterostilbene	Picolinic acid		●■	[84]
	Ethylenediamine		●	[84]
	Ethylenediamine hydrate	N-H···O, O-H···N		[84]
	Theophylline dichloromethane solvate			[84]
	1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane	N-H···O		[84]
	1, 4, 8, 11-Tetraazacyclotetradecane	O-H···N, N-H···N		[84]
	1, 4-Dimethylpiperazine	O-H···N		[84]
	2, 3, 5-Trimethylpirazine	O-H···N		[84]
Ferulic acid	Nicotinamide	O-H···N	▲●	[85]
	Urea	N-H···N	▲●	[85]
	Isonicotinamide	O-H···N	▲●	[86]
Vanillic acid	Caffeine	π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O		[86]
	Theophylline	π-π, C-H···O		[86]
	Theobromine			[86]
	Nicotinamide			[86]
	Isonicotinamide			[86]
	Acridine			[86]
	Urea			[86]
	Andrographolide	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Tinidazole	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O	▲◆	[88]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Resveratrol	Phenazine	C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N		[71]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H···N		[71]
	Piperazine	O-H···O, O-H···N	●	[71]
	1, 10-Phenanthroline	C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N
	1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane			[71]
	Methenamine	O-H···N	●	[71]
	Acridine	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N		[71]
	Succinimide	O-H···O, N-H··O, C-H···O		[71]
	N, N-Dimethyl-4-aminopyridine	O-H···O, O-H··N		[71]
	4-Aminobenzamide		▲●	[72]
	Isoniazid		▲●	[72]
	Amantadine hydrochloride	C-H···Cl, N-H···Cl, O-H···Cl, N-H···O	●■	[73]
	Curcumin		●■	[74]
Bergenin	P-Aminobenzamide	O-H···O, N-H···O	▲●	[58]
	Isonicotinamide	O-H···O, N-H···O	▲●	[58]
	Proline		●	[75]
Oxyresveratrol	Betaine		●	[41]
	L-Proline		●	[41]
	Isonicotinamide		●	[41]
	Nicotinamide		●	[41]
	Urea		●	[41]
	Ethyl maltol		●	[41]
Curcumin	Resveratrol		●■	[74]
	N-Acetylcysteine		●	[76]
	Nicotinamide		●■	[77]
	Ascorbic acid		●	[78]
	Trimellitic anhydride		●■	[79]
	Hydroxyquinolones		■	[79]
Gallic acid	4-Cyanopyridine	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O、O-H···O, N-H···O	●■	[80]
	2, 6-Bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]cyclohexanone	O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[81]
	N-Methyl-3, 5-bis((pyridin-3-yl)methylene)-4-piperidone	O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[81]
	N-Methyl-3, 5-bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]-4-piperidone	O-H···N, O-H···O	■	[81]
	P-Aminobenzoic acid		●■	[82]
	Succinimide		●■	[82]
	Aminoacetic acid		●★	[82]
	L-Proline		●■	[82]
	Glutaric acid		●■	[82]
	Piperazine		■	[82]
	Caffeine		■	[82]
Paeonol	Carbamazepine	O-H···N, O-H···O	●	[83]
Pterostilbene	Picolinic acid		●■	[84]
	Ethylenediamine		●	[84]
	Ethylenediamine hydrate	N-H···O, O-H···N		[84]
	Theophylline dichloromethane solvate			[84]
	1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane	N-H···O		[84]
	1, 4, 8, 11-Tetraazacyclotetradecane	O-H···N, N-H···N		[84]
	1, 4-Dimethylpiperazine	O-H···N		[84]
	2, 3, 5-Trimethylpirazine	O-H···N		[84]
Ferulic acid	Nicotinamide	O-H···N	▲●	[85]
	Urea	N-H···N	▲●	[85]
	Isonicotinamide	O-H···N	▲●	[86]
Vanillic acid	Caffeine	π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O		[86]
	Theophylline	π-π, C-H···O		[86]
	Theobromine			[86]
	Nicotinamide			[86]
	Isonicotinamide			[86]
	Acridine			[86]
	Urea			[86]
	Andrographolide	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Tinidazole	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O	▲◆	[88]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Oridonin	Nicotinamide		●■	[89]
Oleanolic acid	Fumaric acid	O-H···O=C		[90]
	Succinic			[91]
	L-Proline			[91]
	Saccharin			[91]
Betulin	Adipic acid		●	[92]
	Terephthalic acid		●	[93]
Artemisinin	Acetylenedicarboxylic acid		●	[94]
	Orcinol		●	[95]
	Resorcinol		●	[95]
11-Azaartemisinin	Cinnamic	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	Maleic	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	Fumaric acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	5-Bromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	4-Bromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	3, 5-Dibromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	Mefloquine hydrochlorid		▲●	[98]
	L(–)-Malic acid		▲●	[98]
Andrographolide	Vanillin	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Vanillic acid	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Salicylic acid	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O	●	[87]
	Resorcinol	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Guaiacol	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
Celastrol	Threonine		●■	[99]
	Phenylalanine		●■	[99]
	L-Tyrosine		●■	[99]
Scoparone	3, 5-Difluorobenzoic acid	π-π, O-H···O	●	[100]
	Urea	N-H···O, C-H···O	●	[100]
	Pyrimethamine	π-π, N-H···N, N-H···O	●	[100]
	Succinimide	π-π, C-H···O	●	[100]
Emodin	Nicotinamide	O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N		[101]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···Cl, O-H···O, C-H···O		[53]
	Berberine hydrochloride ethanol	O-H···Cl, O-H···O		[53]
	Carbamazepine			[102]
Rhein	Matrine	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O		[67]
	Gefitinib			[103]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Oridonin	Nicotinamide		●■	[89]
Oleanolic acid	Fumaric acid	O-H···O=C		[90]
	Succinic			[91]
	L-Proline			[91]
	Saccharin			[91]
Betulin	Adipic acid		●	[92]
	Terephthalic acid		●	[93]
Artemisinin	Acetylenedicarboxylic acid		●	[94]
	Orcinol		●	[95]
	Resorcinol		●	[95]
11-Azaartemisinin	Cinnamic	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	Maleic	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	Fumaric acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	5-Bromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	4-Bromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	3, 5-Dibromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	Mefloquine hydrochlorid		▲●	[98]
	L(–)-Malic acid		▲●	[98]
Andrographolide	Vanillin	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Vanillic acid	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Salicylic acid	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O	●	[87]
	Resorcinol	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Guaiacol	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
Celastrol	Threonine		●■	[99]
	Phenylalanine		●■	[99]
	L-Tyrosine		●■	[99]
Scoparone	3, 5-Difluorobenzoic acid	π-π, O-H···O	●	[100]
	Urea	N-H···O, C-H···O	●	[100]
	Pyrimethamine	π-π, N-H···N, N-H···O	●	[100]
	Succinimide	π-π, C-H···O	●	[100]
Emodin	Nicotinamide	O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N		[101]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···Cl, O-H···O, C-H···O		[53]
	Berberine hydrochloride ethanol	O-H···Cl, O-H···O		[53]
	Carbamazepine			[102]
Rhein	Matrine	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O		[67]
	Gefitinib			[103]

中药活性成分共晶研究进展

PDF下载

单娅 ¹ , 赵淇 ² , 程燕 ²^,^* , 薛富民 ¹^,²^,^*

药学学报 | 综述 2025,60(6): 1671-1681

收起

药学学报 |综述 2025 , 60 (6) : 1671 -1681

中药活性成分共晶研究进展

全屏

单娅¹, 赵淇², 程燕²^,^*, 薛富民¹^,²^,^*

作者信息

¹山东中医药大学药学院, 山东济南 250355

²齐鲁工业大学 (山东省科学院) 药学院, 山东省分析测试中心, 山东济南 250014

通讯作者:

程燕, Tel: 13370579017, E-mail: yancheng2020@qlu.edu.cn

薛富民, Tel: 18769722218, E-mail: xuefumin@qlu.edu.cn

作者简介:

作者贡献:

单娅负责综述撰写、文献资料收集及修改; 赵淇负责文献修改; 薛富民和程燕负责综述构思和修改; 全体作者都阅读并同意最终版本。

Research progress on the cocrystals of active ingredients of traditional Chinese medicine

Ya SHAN¹, Qi ZHAO², Yan CHENG²^,^*, Fu-min XUE¹^,²^,^*

Affiliations

¹School of Pharmacy, Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Jinan 250355, China

²Shandong Analysis and Test Center, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Qilu University of Technology (Shandong Academy of Sciences), Jinan 250014, China

出版时间: 2025-06-12 doi: 10.16438/j.0513-4870.2024-0798

文章导航

摘要

收起

中药包含众多单体活性成分, 这些成分具有丰富的药理作用。然而, 大多数中药活性成分的理化性质较差, 难以应用于临床。共晶技术在改善中药难溶性有效成分的溶解性和生物利用度等方面具有巨大潜力。本文系统阐述了中药活性成分共晶的研究现状, 并简要介绍了不同类别活性成分的结构与共晶配体结构之间的联系, 旨在为中药活性成分共晶的研究与共晶在医药领域的进一步拓展提供参考。

关键词

中药 / 活性成分 / 共晶 / 黄酮类 / 生物碱类 / 酚类

Abstract

收起

Traditional Chinese medicine contains numerous monomeric active ingredients, which have rich pharmacological effects. However, many of these active ingredients have poor physicochemical properties, making them challenging to use in clinical settings. Cocrystal technology has demonstrated significant potential in enhancing the solubility and bioavailability of these poorly soluble active ingredients. This article provides a comprehensive overview of the current research on cocrystals of active ingredients in traditional Chinese medicine and briefly discusses the relationship between the structures of these active ingredients and the cocrystal formers. The aim is to provide reference for further research on cocrystals of active ingredients of traditional Chinese medicine and their broader applications in the pharmaceutical industry.

Key words

traditional Chinese medicines / active ingredient / cocrystal / flavonoid / alkaloid / phenol

引用本文

单娅, 赵淇, 程燕, 薛富民. 中药活性成分共晶研究进展. 药学学报, 2025 , 60 (6) : 1671 -1681 . DOI: 10.16438/j.0513-4870.2024-0798

Ya SHAN, Qi ZHAO, Yan CHENG, Fu-min XUE. Research progress on the cocrystals of active ingredients of traditional Chinese medicine[J]. Acta Pharmaceutica Sinica, 2025 , 60 (6) : 1671 -1681 . DOI: 10.16438/j.0513-4870.2024-0798

正文

收起

中药活性成分是指中药中具有医疗效用或生理活性的单体化合物, 是药物开发利用的基础。从中药中提取和分离纯化的单体数目繁多, 主要分为黄酮类、生物碱类、酚类、萜类、苯丙素类、糖苷类, 具有抗病毒、抗氧化、抗菌、抗肿瘤、抗疟疾、免疫调节等药理活性, 在疾病的预防或治疗中发挥重要作用。然而, 许多活性成分存在水溶性低、稳定性差、吸湿性高等问题, 限制了其制剂与剂型的开发及临床应用。

共晶是指两种或两种以上不同组分按照一定的化学计量比通过非共价键(氢键、π-π堆积和范德华力等分子间弱作用力) 相互作用形成的结晶物质^[1], 共晶中一种活性组分为药物分子(active pharmaceutical ingredient, API), 另一组分称为共晶配体(cocrystal former, CCF)。药物共晶可在保证或提高中药活性成分的活性前提下, 改善其溶解度、溶出度、稳定性等理化性质, 进而增强药物的生物活性^[2-4]。因此, 中药活性成分共晶的研究对其药物的研发生产及有效利用具有重大意义。本文对中药活性成分共晶的研究进行综述, 以期为中药活性成分共晶的开发研究提供参考。

1　中药活性成分共晶研究进展

收起

1.1　黄酮类

黄酮类化合物以2-苯基色原酮为母核结构, 广泛分布于芸香科、菊科、玄参科、伞形科、苦苣苔科、豆科等被子植物中, 是一类具有抗氧化、抗肿瘤、抗炎等多种药理活性的化合物。然而, 大部分黄酮类化合物存在溶解度差, 口服生物利用度低的问题, 使其临床应用受到了很大的限制。因此, 研究人员通过共晶技术来改善黄酮类化合物的性质。如黄酮醇类化合物槲皮素, 可与多种配体如烟酰胺^[2]、甜菜碱^[3]、茶碱^[3]、L-脯氨酸^[3]、己酮可可碱^[3]等形成共晶。Zhang等^[4]研制了抗血栓药物阿哌沙班-槲皮素共晶, 共晶同时改善了这两种药物的溶解度和生物利用度。Veverka等^[5]研究表明, 槲皮素与吡唑、咪唑烷酮和巴氯芬3种配体形成的共晶在2~20 ℃的各种相对湿度条件下稳定; 槲皮素与N-乙酰胞嘧啶、肉碱和曲酸形成共晶可增强对蛋白酶的抑制活性。同时, 槲皮素-曲酸对人宫颈癌细胞(HeLa) 和人结肠癌细胞(Caco-2) 的细胞毒性较槲皮素有所提高。此外, Liu等^[6]研究表明, 槲皮素-异烟肼共晶也提高了槲皮素的溶解度和生物利用度, 并显著降低了异烟肼的肝毒性。上述研究数据表明, 槲皮素形成共晶后, 在一定程度上提高了槲皮素的稳定性、溶解度、药理活性及生物利用度。

目前, 黄酮类药物共晶的研究取得了较大进展。如表1^[2-49]中统计了16种黄酮类活性成分共晶的研究概况, 在这些共晶中配体多为含氮的环状化合物, 如异烟肼、烟酰胺、哌嗪、4, 4′-联吡啶及生物碱类活性成分咖啡因和茶碱等。共晶形成的相互作用力主要包括氢键、范德华力、卤素键、π-π堆积。这些共晶配体主要通过氢键和π-π堆积等相互作用力与黄酮类活性成分形成共晶。例如, 白杨素分别与4, 4′-联吡啶和1, 4-双(吡啶-4-基甲氧基) 苯通过氢键和π-π堆积相互作用力形成共晶。两种共晶结构中白杨素的-OH通过氢键与两种配体的吡啶环N相连, 形成链状结构。在磷酸盐缓冲液(pH 7.4) 中, 两种共晶的溶解度及溶解速度均较白杨素显著提高, 且细胞毒性研究表明, 其具有良好的生物学适应性^[16]。

药物形成共晶后, 其空间结构发生了改变, 进而改变其理化性质及生物利用度。表1中共晶性质研究数据表明, 黄酮类活性成分形成共晶后, 改善了原料药的生物利用度或药理活性, 除染料木黄酮-脯氨酸共晶外, 其余共晶均提高了原料药的稳定性和溶解度。综上, 几乎所有的黄酮类活性成分共晶均表现出良好的溶解度及口服生物利用度。但部分文献只对共晶的制备表征及晶体空间结构等进行研究, 尚未对其理化性质及生物利用度进行考察, 且药效学及药代学研究只是停留在大鼠等动物身上, 未进行人体临床试验。共晶技术在改善黄酮类化合物的理化性质及生物利用度方面具有重要潜力。然而, 目前针对黄酮类活性成分共晶的研究仍处于初步阶段, 其形成机制、结构特征及性能调控尚需进一步深入探索。

1.2　生物碱类

生物碱是一类含氮碱性有机化合物, 广泛存在于罂粟科、豆科植物、毛茛科等双子叶植物中。生物碱类活性成分具有抗肿瘤、抗病毒、镇痛、抗菌、抗糖尿病和杀虫等广泛的药理活性。大多数生物碱具有复杂的环状结构, 含有碱性氮原子、芳香环、杂环结构和含氮基团等。目前, 生物碱类活性成分的共晶研究主要以小檗碱、茶碱、咖啡因居多, 川穹嗪、延胡索乙素、四氢小檗碱等共晶的数量相对较少。

表2^{[13, 14, 20, 25, 26, 28, 36, 37, 42, 50-70]}统计了10种生物碱类活性成分的研究概况。生物碱类活性成分多数含有N杂环, 其中的N原子可以参与氢键的生成。因此, 生物碱类活性成分多被用作共晶配体与黄酮类活性成分形成共晶, 以改善药物的溶解度和生物利用度。如Li等^[42]报道了染料木黄酮-川芎嗪共晶晶格中染料木黄酮的两个羟基分别与两分子川芎嗪中吡嗪环上N原子以O-H···N氢键相互作用形成一维链。在大鼠口服给药后, 染料木素-川芎嗪共晶的C_max及生物利用度分别是纯染料木黄酮的5.49和1.84倍。同时, 该共晶还改善了川芎嗪的易升华的缺点。此外, 盐酸小檗碱常用作配体与天然药物杨梅素^[25]、二氢杨梅素^[25]、白杨素^[14]、大黄素^[53]等形成共晶, 以改善天然药物的溶解度和生物利用度。

生物碱类活性成分除作为共晶配体外, 还可与磺酸类和带羧基的化学药物形成共晶。如卢琪^[50]制备的盐酸小檗碱-柠檬酸共晶、盐酸小檗碱-乳酸共晶，以及相关文献报道的盐酸小檗碱-L(+)-乳酸-水合物共晶^[51]和盐酸小檗碱-富马酸共晶^[52]。这些共晶的稳定性和溶解度与盐酸小檗碱相比有显著的提高。He等^[54]制备了小檗碱-罗格列酮共晶, 改善了糖尿病KKAy小鼠的糖脂代谢和胰岛素抵抗。吕扬等^[55]采用加液球磨法制备了小檗碱-布洛芬共晶。该共晶改善了原料药在水和盐酸混合体系中的释放情况, 提高了溶解速率和药物在大鼠体内的吸收速度与血药浓度, 并延长了作用时间。表2中生物碱类活性成分共晶性质的研究结果表明, 只有茶碱-阿魏酸共晶、可可碱-1-羟基-2-萘甲酸共晶的溶解度较原料药低, 其余共晶均提高了生物碱类原料药的溶解度。因此, 生物碱类活性成分共晶可改变原料药的理化性质, 但目前研究仍不够深入, 仍需继续探索。

1.3　酚类

酚类是芳香环上的氢被羟基取代的一类芳香族化合物, 具有抗菌、抗炎和抗氧化等多种药理作用。酚类化合物由于含有羟基, 易与含有羟基、羧基及含氮杂环的药物产生相互作用力形成共晶, 如哌嗪、烟酰胺、异烟肼、茶碱等共晶配体。酚类化合物共晶的研究概况于表3^{[41, 58, 71-88]}, 包括9种酚类活性成分。其中白藜芦醇、香草酸、姜黄素、没食子酸的共晶研究较多。

多酚化合物白藜芦醇, 具有抗炎、抗病毒、保护心血管和神经等作用。但白藜芦醇溶解性差, 代谢快, 导致生物利用度低。Mehta等^[71]采用液体辅助研磨制备了白藜芦醇与多种配体的共晶。溶解度实验表明, 白藜芦醇与配体哌嗪和六亚甲基四胺共晶的溶解度分别为白藜芦醇的2.5和1.5倍。两种共晶均提高了白藜芦醇的溶解度。Zhou等^[72]以乙醇为溶剂, 采用液体辅助研磨和快速除溶剂方法合成了白藜芦醇-4-氨基苯甲酰胺共晶和白藜芦醇-异烟肼共晶。这两种共晶提高了白藜芦醇的溶解度和稳定性, 并具有良好的机械性能, 更适合片剂制剂开发。Wang等^[73]将其与抗病毒药物盐酸金刚烷胺制成共晶。结果表明, 该共晶提高了白藜芦醇的溶解度152倍, 相对生物利用度9.62倍, 并且降低了盐酸金刚烷胺释放速率, 减轻了因盐酸金刚烷胺溶解度过高而引起的毒性作用风险, 协同增强抗病毒作用。此外, Dal Magro等^[74]通过超临界溶剂共结晶技术合成姜黄素-白藜芦醇的共晶, 并提高了白藜芦醇的抗氧化活性和溶解度。

1.4　萜类及其他活性成分

除上述黄酮类、生物碱类、酚类活性成分外, 萜类、香豆素类和蒽醌类活性成分的共晶也有研究。表4^{[53, 67, 87, 89-103]}概括了萜类及其他活性成分共晶的研究概况, 包括10种活性成分。萜类化合物是由甲戊二羟酸衍生、并以异戊二烯单元为基本的化合物及其衍生物, 广泛存在于自然界中, 具有抗肿瘤、抗氧化、抑菌等药理活性。其中, 如五环三萜类化合物白桦脂醇结构中含有一个羟基和一个羧基, 可与己二酸、辛二酸和对苯二甲酸形成共晶提高其溶解度。Jia等^[89]采用旋转蒸发法制备了二萜类化合物冬凌草甲素与烟酰胺的共晶。实验结果表明, 冬凌草甲素-烟酰胺共晶提高了冬凌草甲素的溶解性和生物利用度, 增强了冬凌草甲素对HepG2细胞的抑制作用, 并通过细胞代谢组学预测冬凌草甲素-烟酰胺共晶调控与细胞凋亡和迁移相关的代谢途径来抑制肿瘤细胞生长。

Nisar等^[96]采用液体辅助研磨法制备了11-氮杂青蒿素与反式肉桂酸、马来酸和富马酸的共晶, 这3种共晶的形成主要通过药物与配体之间的N-H···O和O-H···O氢键相互作用力连接。此外, Roy等^[97]报告了11-氮杂青蒿素与5-溴-水杨酸、4-溴-水杨酸和3, 5-二溴水杨酸的共晶。Nisar等^[98]还采用溶液法制备了11-氮杂青蒿素与喹啉抗疟药盐酸甲氟喹和L(-)-苹果酸的共晶, 极大改善了11-氮杂青蒿素的热稳定性和溶解度。且晶体结构分析表明, 在这两种共晶中, 11-氮杂青蒿素的酰胺官能团既可作为氢键供体也可作为氢键受体。

其他活性成分如香豆素类化合物的共晶也有研究。Chen等^[100]采用溶液结晶法制得了滨蒿内酯与3, 5-二氟苯甲酸、尿素、乙胺嘧啶和琥珀酰亚胺的4种共晶。其中, 滨蒿内酯-3, 5-二氟苯甲酸共晶的不对称单元含有一分子滨蒿内酯和一分子3, 5-二氟苯甲酸。滨蒿内酯通过O-H···O氢键与3, 5-二氟苯甲酸分子交替连接, 形成两条方向相反的链。相邻的链进一步反向连接, 形成二维网状结构，进而通过π-π相互作用堆积形成稳定的晶体。滨蒿内酯-尿素共晶的不对称单元包含两分子滨蒿内酯和两分子尿素, 通过N-H···和C-H···O氢键相互作用形成晶体结构。滨蒿内酯-乙胺嘧啶共晶的不对称单元中具有一分子滨蒿内酯和两分子乙胺嘧啶, 通过π-π、N-H···N和N-H···O相互作用形成晶体结构。滨蒿内酯-琥珀酰亚胺不对称单元中有一分子滨蒿内酯和一分子琥珀酰亚胺。该晶体结构以π-π和C-H···O弱氢键相互作用形成堆积结构。此外, 表观溶解度研究结果表明，滨蒿内酯-尿素共晶的溶解度较滨蒿内酯的两种晶型更高。但尚未有其药效学和药动学的相关研究, 未来仍需进一步探索。

2　展望与挑战

收起

综上所述, 文中报道了45种中药活性成分药物共晶研究。其中, 黄酮类活性成分共晶的研究最为广泛。药物和共晶配体主要通过羰基、酰胺和羟基等官能团产生相互作用力形成共晶。此外, 配体、温度、溶剂、pH值和离子浓度等因素均可能影响共晶的形成。本文所述的16种黄酮类化合物结构中含有多个羟基, 易与含氮环状化合物配体产生氢键和π-π堆积等相互作用力形成共晶; 生物碱类活性成分由于含有氮原子, 常用作配体改善黄酮类活性成分的理化性质, 也易与磺酸类和具有羧基的药物形成共晶; 酚类活性成分易与含氮杂环的药物形成共晶; 萜类活性成分主要与有机酸类配体形成共晶。

药物共晶不仅可改善中药活性成分的物理化学性质, 还可以作为一种新的联合用药方式, 将会进一步提高中药活性成分的应用价值。但目前中药活性成分共晶的研究多选用含氮环状结构如烟酰胺、异烟肼和4, 4′-联吡啶等分子作为共晶配体, 在配体的选择上尚存在一定的局限性。尽管近几年中药活性成分共晶的相关研究逐渐增加, 但大多都停留在晶体结构分析和溶解度研究上, 在体内的作用过程及其毒理药理作用机制的研究较少, 并且中药活性成分共晶与剂型相结合的报道也不多。因此, 中药活性成分共晶离临床应用还有很长的距离, 比如共晶是否符合药典和法律的相关规定, 是否可大规模制备生产等还需对中药活性成分共晶深入研究, 以获得更多的支撑数据。随着国家把发展中医药创新推向前所未有的高度, 中药活性成分共晶将会获得科研人员越来越多的研究。

参考文献

收起

文献

收起

参考文献引证文献

排序方式：

Aitipamula S, Banerjee R, Bansal AK, et al. Polymorphs, salts, and cocrystals: what's in a name? [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2012, 12: 2147-2152.

Wu N, Zhang Y, Ren J, et al. Preparation of quercetin-nicotinamide cocrystals and their evaluation under in vivo and in vitro conditions [J]. RSC Adv, 2020, 10: 21852-21859.

Haskins MM, Kavanagh ON, Sanii R, et al. Tuning the pharmacokinetic performance of quercetin by cocrystallization [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2023, 23: 6059-6066.

Zhang L, Kong DW, Wang HJ, et al. Cocrystal of apixaban-quercetin: improving solubility and bioavailability of drug combination of two poorly soluble drugs [J]. Molecules, 2021, 26: 2677.

Veverka M, Dubaj T, Gallovic J, et al. Cocrystals of quercetin: synthesis, characterization, and screening of biological activity [J]. Monatsh Chem, 2015, 146: 99-109.

Liu F, Wang LY, Yu MC, et al. A new cocrystal of isoniazid-quercetin with hepatoprotective effect: the design, structure, and in vitro/in vivo performance evaluation [J]. Eur J Pharm Sci, 2020, 144: 105216.

He HY, Huang Y, Zhang Q, et al. Zwitterionic cocrystals of flavonoids and proline: solid-state characterization, pharmaceutical properties, and pharmacokinetic performance [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2016, 16: 2348-2356.

Yan LY, Sheng LS, Song JK, et al. Characterization and preliminary pharmacokinetic study of cocrystals of osmanthus and piperazine [J]. Herald Med (医药导报), 2022, 41: 621-625.

Luo Y, Chen S, Zhou J, et al. Luteolin cocrystals: characterization, evaluation of solubility, oral bioavailability and theoretical calculation [J]. J Drug Deliv Sci Technol, 2019, 50: 248-254.

Wang YR. Study of Quercetin and Luteolin Co-amorphous Solids Dispersion or Co-crystals Using Amino Acids as Co-former (氨基酸为共配体槲皮素、木犀草素共无定型态固体分散体或共晶研究)[D]. Guilin: Guilin Medical University, 2021.

Sowa M, Slepokura K, Matczak-Jon E. Cocrystals of fisetin, luteolin and genistein with pyridinecarboxamide coformers: crystal structures, analysis of intermolecular interactions, spectral and thermal characterization [J]. CrystEngComm, 2013, 15: 7696-7708.

Liu LX, Zou DY, Zhang YN, et al. Anti-inflammatory effect of the luteolin·4, 4′-dipyridy co-crystal on macrophage RAW264.7 in mice [J]. China Pharm (中国药房), 2018, 29: 602-606.

Li JY. Cocrystallization Study of Improving the Pharmacological Activity of Flavonoids and Reducing Hepatotoxicity of Anti-tuberculosis Drugs (以改善黄酮类化合物药学活性和降低抗结核药物肝毒性为目的的共晶研究) [D]. Liaocheng: Liaocheng University, 2023.

Sa RJ, Zhang YJ, Deng YP, et al. Novel salt cocrystal of chrysin with berberine: preparation, characterization, and oral bioavailability [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2018, 18: 4724-4730.

Chadha R, Bhalla Y, Nandan A, et al. Chrysin cocrystals: characterization and evaluation [J]. J Pharm Biomed Anal, 2017, 134: 361-371.

Pang X. A Study Based on the Adsorption, Detection and Solubility of Three Phenolic Compounds (基于三种酚类化合物的吸附、检测和溶出度研究) [D]. Haikou: Hainan University, 2023.

Zhang YN, Yin HM, Zhang Y, et al. Synthesis and antiumor activities of kaempherol pharmaceutical cocrystal with 4, 4′- dipyridine [J]. J Nat Sci Heilongjiang Univ (黑龙江大学自然科学学报), 2015, 32: 792-797.

Zhou HL, Duan CX, Qin HM, et al. Synthesis and structural characterization of a novel palbociclib-kaempferol cocrystal with improved tabletability and synergistic antitumor activity [J]. J Mol Struct, 2023, 1281: 135101.

Lu WT. Study on Co-crystls of Lenvatinib, Olaparib and Drug-Drug Cocrystal of 5-Fluorouracil and Kaempferol (乐伐替尼、奥拉帕尼的共晶以及5-氟尿嘧啶-山柰酚药物-药物共晶的研究) [D]. Tianjin: Tianjin University of Technology, 2021.

Zhang YN, Yin HM, Zhang Y, et al. Cocrystals of kaempferol, quercetin and myricetin with 4, 4′-bipyridine: crystal structures, analyses of intermolecular interactions and antibacterial properties [J]. J Mol Struct, 2017, 1130: 199-207.

Hong C, Xie Y, Yao YS, et al. A novel strategy for pharmaceutical cocrystal generation without knowledge of stoichiometric ratio: myricetin cocrystals and a ternary phase diagrams [J]. Pharm Res, 2015, 32: 47-60.

Xu JJ, Wei YF, Qian S, et al. Preparation of myricetin-caffeine cocrystal and its single crystal analysis [J]. J China Pharm Univ (中国药科大学学报), 2016, 47: 324-328.

Liu MY, Hong C, Yao YS, et al. Development of a pharmaceutical cocrystal with solution crystallization technology: preparation, characterization, and evaluation of myricetin-proline cocrystals [J]. Eur J Pharm Biopharm, 2016, 107: 151-159.

Zhang M, Gu DL, Zhen JF, et al. A novel drug-drug cocrystal of tegafur and myricetin: optimized properties of dissolution and tabletability [J]. CrystEngComm, 2023, 25: 6171-6179.

Li PZ, Ramaiah T, Zhang M, et al. Two cocrystals of berberine chloride with myricetin and dihydromyricetin: crystal structures, characterization, and antitumor activities [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2019, 20: 157-166.

Wang CG. Study the Chirality and Solid Form of Dihydromyricetin: Based on Assessment of Pharmacokinetic Parameter (基于药代动力学性质的藤茶中二氢杨梅素构型和晶型研究)[D]. Wuhan: Huazhong University of Science and Technology, 2017.

Liu L, Li YG, Zhang M, et al. A drug-drug cocrystal of dihydromyricetin and pentoxifylline [J]. J Pharm Sci, 2022, 111: 82-87.

Huang S, Xue Q, Xu J, et al. Simultaneously improving the physicochemical properties, dissolution performance, and bioavailability of apigenin and daidzein by co-crystallization with theophylline [J]. J Pharm Sci, 2019, 108: 2982-2993.

Sun YT, Guo M, Zhao XX, et al. Imaging supermolecular interactions of the pharmaceutical-cocrystal of apigenin-nicotinamide binding with serum albumin [J]. Turk J Chem, 2023, 47: 554-571.

Sheng LS, Ren LW, Yang SY, et al. Apigenin-piperazine co-crystal: preparation, characterization and in vitro anti-tumor efficacy [J]. Chin J New Drugs (中国新药杂志), 2022, 31: 679-684.

Ma XQ, Zhuang C, Wang BC, et al. Cocrystal of apigenin with higher solubility, enhanced oral bioavailability, and anti-inflammatory effect [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2019, 19: 5531-5537.

Jin Y, Lu X, Jiang CJ. Preparation and characterization of puerarin-piracetammde cocrystal [J]. J Zhejiang Univ Sci Technol (浙江科技学院学报), 2019, 31: 30-35.

Inam M, Liu L, Wang JW, et al. Enhancing the physiochemical properties of puerarin via L-proline co-crystallization: synthesis, characterization, and dissolution studies of two phases of pharmaceutical co-crystals [J]. Int J Mol Sci, 2021, 22: 928.

Hua Y, Wu YS, Zheng DY, et al. Enhanced dissolution and tabletability of lornoxicam by cocrystallization [J]. Acta Pharm Sin (药学学报), 2022, 57: 1163-1171.

Inam M, Jamshed M, Rehman I, et al. Impact of L-pyroglutamic acid on the solubility of puerarin: preparation, solid-state characterization and physicochemical evaluation of puerarin-L-pyroglutamic acid co-crystal [J]. J Mex Chem Soc, 2023, 67: 143-151.

Li W, Pi JX, Zhang Y, et al. A strategy to improve the oral availability of baicalein: the baicalein-theophylline cocrystal [J]. Fitoterapia, 2018, 129: 85-93.

Zhu BQ, Zhang Q, Wang JR, et al. Cocrystals of baicalein with higher solubility and enhanced bioavailability [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2017, 17: 1893-1901.

Huang YT, Zhang BW, Gao Y, et al. Baicalein-nicotinamide cocrystal with enhanced solubility, dissolution, and oral bioavailability [J]. J Pharm Sci, 2014, 103: 2330-2337.

Sowa M, Slepokura K, Matczak-Jon E. Improving solubility of fisetin by cocrystallization [J]. CrystEngComm, 2014, 16: 10592-10601.

Sowa M, Slepokura K, Matczak-Jon E. Solid-state characterization and solubility of a genistein-caffeine cocrystal [J]. J Mol Struct, 2014, 1076: 80-88.

Sowa M, Slepokura K, Matczak-Jon E. A 1∶2 cocrystal of genistein with isonicotinamide: crystal structure and hirshfeld surface analysis [J]. Acta Crystallogr Sect C Struct Chem, 2013, 69: 1267-1272.

Li XJ, Liu XN, Song JM, et al. Drug-drug cocrystallization simultaneously improves pharmaceutical properties of genistein and ligustrazine [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2021, 21: 3461-3468.

Luo C, Liang WD, Chen X, et al. Pharmaceutical cocrystals of naringenin with improved dissolution performance [J]. CrystEngComm, 2018, 20: 3025-3033.

Khandavilli UBR, Skorepová E, Sinha AS, et al. Cocrystals and a salt of the bioactive flavonoid: naringenin [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2018, 18: 4571-4577.

Chadha K, Karan M, Bhallla Y, et al. Cocrystals of hesperetin: structural, pharmacokinetic, and pharmacodynamic evaluation [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2017, 17: 2386-2405.

Wang J, Dai XL, Lu TB, et al. Temozolomide-hesperetin drug-drug cocrystal with optimized performance in stability, dissolution, and tabletability [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2021, 21: 838-846.

Bolus L, Wang K, Pask C, et al. Cocrystallisation of daidzein with pyridine-derived molecules: screening, structure determination and characterisationn [J]. J Mol Struct, 2020, 1222: 128893.

Xu J, Huang YT, Ruan SD, et al. Cocrystals of isoliquiritigenin with enhanced pharmacokinetic performance [J]. CrystEngComm, 2016, 18: 8776-8786.

Huang S, Xu J, Peng YY, et al. Facile tuning of the photoluminescence and dissolution properties of phloretin through cocrystallization [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2019, 19: 6837-6844.

Lu Q. Preparation, Characterization and Property Study of Berberine Chloride and Citric Acid/Lactic Acid Co-cocrystal (盐酸小檗碱与柠檬酸/乳酸共晶的制备、表征与性质研究) [D]. Shanghai: Shanghai University of Engineering Science, 2019.

Wang LL, Liu SY, Gao ZY. Crystal structure, dissolution and hygroscopicity of a novel cocrystal hydrate of berberine hydrochloride with L(+)-lactic acid [J]. Pharmazie, 2020, 75: 483-487.

Yang DZ, Cao JZ, Jiao LT, et al. Solubility and stability advantages of a new cocrystal of berberine chloride with fumaric acid [J]. ACS Omega, 2020, 5: 8283-8292.

Deng YP, Zhang YJ, Huang YL, et al. Preparation, crystal structures, and oral bioavailability of two cocrystals of emodin with berberine chloride [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2018, 18: 7481-7488.

He QC, Chen B, Wang G, et al. Co-crystal of rosiglitazone with berberine ameliorates hyperglycemia and insulin resistance through the PI3K/AKT/TXNIP pathway in vivo and in vitro [J]. Front Pharmacol, 2022, 13: 842879.

Lu Y, Du GH, Cao JZ, et al. Co-crystal of berberine hydrochloride and ibuprofen, preparation method, composition and application: China, CN110041325B [P]. 2023-04-11.

Li AF, Liu HF, Liu XM. Preparation of theophylline-paracetamol co-crystal by ball-milling method [J]. Mod Chem Ind (现代化工), 2015, 35: 57-60.

Velmurugan V, Asha RN, Nayagam BRD, et al. Synthesis, characterization and biological activity of (phenylthio) acetic acid: theophylline cocrystal [J]. J Chem Crystallogr, 2021, 51: 225-234.

Liu HJ. Cocrystal Design and Its Solid-State Chemical Properties Investigation of Two Natural Products (两种天然产物的共晶设计及其固体化学性质研究) [D]. Guangzhou: Southern Medical University, 2022.

Aher S, Dhumal R, Mahadik K, et al. Effect of cocrystallization techniques on compressional properties of caffeine/oxalic acid 2∶1 cocrystal [J]. Pharm Dev Technol, 2013, 18: 55-60.

Pal S, Roopa BN, Abu K, et al. Thermal studies of furosemide-caffeine binary system that forms a cocrystal [J]. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2014, 115: 2261-2268.

Szell PMJ, Dragon J, Zablotny S, et al. Mechanochemistry and cocrystallization of 3-iodoethynylbenzoic acid with nitrogen-containing heterocycles: concurrent halogen and hydrogen bonding [J]. New J Chem, 2018, 42: 10493-10501.

Ren SY, Jiao LT, Yang SY, et al. A novel co-crystal of bexarotene and ligustrazine improves pharmacokinetics and tissue distribution of bexarotene in SD rats [J]. Pharmaceutics, 2020, 12: 906.

Yuan XY, Cheng Y, Liu J, et al. Six novel multicomponent systems of theobromine with carboxylic acids: crystallographic structures, solubility determination and DFT calculations [J]. CrystEngComm, 2023, 25: 5682-5696.

Zhang DJ. Synthesis and Properties of Pharmaceutical Cocrysyals of Tetrahydroberberine (四氢小檗碱药物共晶的合成及性质研究) [D]. Jiamusi: Jiamusi University, 2019.

Su X. Synthesis and Properties of Pharmaceutical Cocrystals of Tetrahydropalmatine (延胡索乙素药物共晶的合成及性质研究) [D]. Jiamusi: Jiamusi University, 2019.

Mao L, Liu LM, Liu YC, et al. Synthesis and antitumor activities of iron (Ⅲ) compound with matrine [J]. J Guangxi Norm Univ (Nat Sci Ed) [广西师范大学学报(自然科学版)], 2008, 2: 60-63.

Wang HJ, Yang DZ, Zhang W, et al. An innovative rhein-matrine cocrystal: synthesis, characterization, formation mechanism and pharmacokinetic study [J]. Chin Chem Lett, 2023, 34: 107258.

Yang J, Miao MM, Chen YK, et al. Structural analysis of nicotine tartrate crystals [J]. Chem Res Appl (化学研究与应用), 2019, 31: 2048-2054.

Li ZQ, Huang JH, Lei P, et al. Preparation of nicotine malite and theoretical analysis of its crystal structure [J]. China Meas Test (中国测试), 2019, 45: 53-61.

Smith G, Wermuth UD. Crystal structures and hydrogen bonding in the proton-transfer salts of nicotine with 3, 5-di-nitrosalicylic acid and 5-sulfosalicylic acid [J]. Acta Crystallogr Sect E Struct Rep Online, 2014, 70: 430-434.

Mehta BK, Singh SS, Chaturvedi S, et al. Rational coformer selection and the development of new crystalline multicomponent forms of resveratrol with enhanced water solubility [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2018, 18: 1581-1592.

Zhou ZZ, Li WY, Sun WJ, et al. Resveratrol cocrystals with enhanced solubility and tabletability [J]. Int J Pharm, 2016, 509: 391-399.

Wang LY, Zhao MY, Bu FZ, et al. Cocrystallization of amantadine hydrochloride with resveratrol: the first drug-nutraceutical cocrystal displaying synergistic antiviral activity [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2021, 21: 2763-2776.

Dal Magro C, dos Santos AE, Ribas MM, et al. Production of curcumin-resveratrol cocrystal using cocrystallization with supercritical solvent [J]. J Supercrit Fluids, 2021, 171: 105190.

Zhang LH. Preparation, Characterization and Preliminary Quality Evaluation of Bergenin Proline Cocrystals (岩白菜素-脯氨酸共晶的制备、表征与初步质量评价) [D]. Chengdu: Chengdu Medical College, 2023.

Ribas MM, Sakata GSB, Santos AE, et al. Curcumin cocrystals using supercritical fluid technology [J]. J Supercrit Fluids, 2019, 152: 104564.

Ribas MM, Aguiar GPS, Muller LG, et al. Curcumin-nicotinamide cocrystallization with supercritical solvent (CSS): synthesis, characterization and in vivo antinociceptive and anti-inflammatory activities [J]. Ind Crops Prod, 2019, 139: 111537.

Pantwalawalkar J, More H, Bhange D, et al. Novel curcumin ascorbic acid cocrystal for improved solubility [J]. J Drug Deliv Sci Technol, 2021, 61: 102233.

Sathisaran I, Devidas Bhatia D, Vishvanath Dalvi S. New curcumin-trimesic acid cocrystal and anti-invasion activity of curcumin multicomponent solids against 3D tumor models [J]. Int J Pharm, 2020, 587: 119667.

Goswami S, Ghosh A, Borah K, et al. Structure-property correlation in gallic acid and 4-cyanopyridine cocrystal and binding studies with drug efflux pump in bacteria [J]. J Mol Struct, 2021, 1225: 129279.

Liu LD, Liu SL, Liu ZX, et al. Synthesis, structure, antitumor activity of novel pharmaceutical co-crystals based on bispyridyl-substituted α, β-unsaturated ketones with gallic acid [J]. J Mol Struct, 2016, 1112: 1-8.

Xue N. Screening and Evaluation of Hypoglycemic Supramolecular System Based on Chinese Herbal Active Ingredients Gallic Acid (以中药单体没食子酸为基础的降糖超分子体系的筛选及评价)[D]. Shijiazhuang: Hebei Medical University, 2019.

Huang DD. Study on the Dissolution Kinetics of Carbamazepine "Drug and Drug Co-crystals" in Solution (卡马西平"药-药共晶"在溶液中的溶解动力学研究) [D]. Guangzhou: Southern Medical University, 2021.

Bofill L, Barbas R, De Sande D, et al. A novel, extremely bioavailable cocrystal of pterostilbene [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2021, 21: 2315-2323.

Aitipamula S, Das S. Cocrystal formulations: a case study of topical formulations consisting of ferulic acid cocrystals [J]. Eur J Pharm Biopharm, 2020, 149: 95-104.

Jacobs A, Noa FMA. Co-crystals and co-crystal hydrates of vanillic acid [J]. CrystEngComm, 2015, 17: 98-106.

Suresh K, Goud NR, Nangia A. Andrographolide: solving chemical instabilty and poor solubility by means of cocrystals [J]. Chem Asian J, 2013, 8: 3032-3041.

Zheng K, Xie CJ, Li XW, et al. Crystal structures, thermal stabilities, and dissolution behaviours of tinidazole and the tinidazole-vanillic acid cocrystal: insights from energy frameworks [J]. Acta Crystallogr Sect C Struct Chem, 2020, 76: 389-397.

Jia XM, Hao H, Zhang Q, et al. The bioavailability enhancement and insight into the action mechanism of poorly soluble natural compounds from co-crystals preparation: oridonin as an example [J]. Phytomedicine, 2023, 122: 155179.

Ren TK, Zhang YR, Liu XY, et al. Preparation and thermodynamics of oleanolic acid co-crystals [J]. Chin J Pharm (中国医药工业杂志), 2014, 45: 649-652.

Chen PY. Screening Co-crystals Based on the Oleanolic Acid and Study on Its Interaction with Bovine Serum Albumin by Fluorescence Spectrometry (齐墩果酸共晶的筛选及其与牛血清白蛋白相互作用的光谱学研究)[D]. Shijiazhuang: Hebei Medical University, 2017.

Myz AS, Mikhailovskaya VA, Mikhailenko AM, et al. New crystalline betulin-based materials: improving betulin solubility via cocrystal formation [J]. Mater Today Proc, 2019, 12: 82-85.

Mikhailovskaya VA, Myz AS, Bulina VN, et al. Screening and characterization of cocrystal formation between betulin and terephthalic acid [J]. Mater Today Proc, 2020, 25: 381-383.

Makadia J, Madu SJ, Arroo R, et al. Artemisinin-acetylenedicar-boxylic acid cocrystal: screening, structure determination, and physicochemical property characterisation [J]. CrystEngComm, 2022, 24: 1056-1067.

Kaur M, Yardley V, Wang K, et al. Artemisinin cocrystals for bioavailability enhancement. Part 1: formulation design and role of the polymeric excipient [J]. Mol Pharm, 2021, 18: 4256-4271.

Nisar M, Wong LWY, Sung HHY, et al. Cocrystals of the antimalarial drug 11-azaartemisinin with three alkenoic acids of 1∶1 or 2∶1 stoichiometry [J]. Acta Crystallogr Sect C Struct Chem, 2018, 74: 742-751.

Roy M, Li KY, Nisar M, et al. Varying degrees of homostructurality in a series of cocrystals of antimalarial drug 11-azaartemisinin with salicylic acids [J]. Acta Crystallogr Sect C Struct Chem, 2021, 77: 262-270.

Nisar M, Haynes RK, Sung HHY, et al. Mechanochemical conversion of 11-azaartemisinin into pharmaceutical cocrystals with improved solubility [J]. Acta Crystallogr Sect A Found Adv, 2017, 73: a268.

Wu XX, Chen K, Tian QK, et al. Amino acid cocrystal of celastrol wilfordii extract and its preparation method and application: CN, 201910557148.8 [P]. 2022-07-12.

100

Chen JY, Wang XY, Hong MH, et al. Structure properties of scoparone: polymorphs and cocrystals [J]. J Mol Struct, 2019, 1191: 323-336.

101

Park B, Yoon W, Yun J, et al. Emodin-nicotinamide (1∶2) cocrystal identified by thermal screening to improve emodin solubility [J]. Int J Pharm, 2019, 557: 26-35.

102

Huang DD, Stephen HCS, Wu YS, et al. Phase solubility investigation and theoretical calculations on drug-drug cocrystals of carbamazepine weith emodin, paeonol [J]. J Mol Liq, 2021, 329: 115604.

103

Zhang F, Long XT, Ren BY, et al. Three polymorphs and two hydrates of a multidrug crystal involving gefitinib and rhein: characterization, stability, and solubility aspects [J]. Cryst Growth Des, 2024, 24: 4501-4509.

2025年第60卷第6期

PDF下载

196

引用本文

BibTeX

文章信息

doi: 10.16438/j.0513-4870.2024-0798

接收时间：2024-08-19
首发时间：2026-09-20
出版时间：2025-06-12

补充材料

相关文章

文章信息

作者

出版历史

收稿日期：2024-08-19
修回日期：2024-11-14

基金

作者信息

¹山东中医药大学药学院, 山东济南 250355

²齐鲁工业大学 (山东省科学院) 药学院, 山东省分析测试中心, 山东济南 250014

通讯作者:

程燕, Tel: 13370579017, E-mail: yancheng2020@qlu.edu.cn

薛富民, Tel: 18769722218, E-mail: xuefumin@qlu.edu.cn

参考文献

分享链接

https://castjournals.cast.org.cn/joweb/yxxb/CN/10.16438/j.0513-4870.2024-0798

分享至

全文二维码

扫描看全文

引用本文

BibTeX

本文的引用情况

2种不同金属材料的力学参数

科 Family	属数 Number of genus	种数 Number of species	占总种数比例 Percentage of total species (%)	属 Genus	种数 Number of species	占总种数比例 Percentage of total species (%)
鹅膏菌科Amanitaceae	2	11	5.26	鹅膏菌属 Amanita	10	4.78
小菇科 Mycenaceae	2	12	5.74	丝盖伞属 Inocybe	5	2.39
多孔菌科 Polyporaceae	8	14	6.70	蜡蘑属 Laccaria	5	2.39
红菇科 Russulaceae	3	23	11.00	小皮伞属 Marasmius	6	2.87
				小菇属 Mycena	11	5.26
				光柄菇属 Pluteus	5	2.39
				红菇属 Russula	17	8.13
				栓菌属 Trametes	5	2.39

关闭全屏

BibTeX
EndNote
RefWorks
TxT

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Quercetin	Nicotinamide		●■	[2]
	Betaine		●■	[3]
	Theophylline		●■	[3]
	L-Proline		●■	[3]
	Pentoxifylline		●■	[3]
	Apixaban	O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[4]
	Pyrazol			[5]
	Imidazolidinone			[5]
	Baclofen			[5]
	N-Acetylcytosine		■	[5]
	Carnitine		■	[5]
	Kojic acid		■	[5]
	Isoniazid		●■	[6]
Luteolin	L-Proline	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O	■	[7]
	Piperazine		▲	[8]
	Isoniazid	C-H···N, N-H···N	▲●	[9]
	Caffeine		▲●■	[9]
	Lysine		▲●	[10]
	Arginine		▲●	[10]
	Isonicotinamide			[11]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine		■	[12]
Chrysin	Piperazine		●	[13]
	Ethionamide	O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O N-H···O, N-H···S		[13]
	Berberine hydrochloride		■	[14]
	Cytosine	π-π, C-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[15]
	Thiamine hydrochloride	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, N-H···Cl	●	[15]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[16]
	1, 4-Bis(pyridin-4-ylmethoxy) benzene	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[16]
Kaempferol	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[17]
	Piperazine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O N-H···O, N-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Tetramethylprazine	C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Pyrazinamide	π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O N-H···O, O-H···O	▲●	[13]
	Palbociclib	O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O	▲●■	[18]
	5-Fluorouracil		●■	[19]
Myricetin	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	■	[20]
	Nicotinamide		●	[21]
	Isonicotinamide		●	[21]
	4-Cyanopyridine		●	[21]
	Caffeine	O-H···O, O-H···N	●	[22]
	Proline	O-H···O, C-O···N	●■	[23]
	Tetramethylprazine	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	●	[13]
	Tegafur		▲●	[24]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
Dihydromyricetin	Theophylline	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N O-H···N, O-H···O=C	▲●	[26]
	Benzamide	N-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···O		[26]
	Caffeine	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N O-H···N, O-H···O=C	●	[26]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Pentoxifylline		●■	[27]
Apigenin	Theophylline	O-H···N	●■	[28]
	Nicotinamide		●	[29]
	Piperazine		●■	[30]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[31]
Daidzeine	Piracetam		●	[32]
	L-Proline		●	[33]
	Lornoxicam		▲●	[34]
	L-Pyroglutamic acid		●	[35]
Baicalein	Theophylline	O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N	●■	[36]
	Caffeine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[37]
	Nicotinamide	O-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···C=O N-H···C=O	●■	[38]
Fisetin	Isonicotinamide	C-H···O, N-H···O	●	[39]
	Nicotinamide/ hemiethanolate (1∶2)	N-H···O, O-H···O, O-C···N	●	[39]
	Nicotinamide		●	[39]
	Caffeine		●	[39]
Genistein	Proline		▼◆	[7]
	Nicotinamide			[11]
	Caffeine	π-π, C-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···O	▲●	[40]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[41]
	Tetramethylpyrazine	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲●■	[42]
Naringenin	Isonicotinamide	π-π, O-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O=C	●■	[43]
	Picolinic acid		●	[43]
	Betaine	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···O=C	●	[43]
	Flavone	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···O=C	●	[44]
	4-Hydroxypyridine	O-H···O, N-H···O	●	[44]
	Anthranilamide	O-H··N, O-H···O, N-H··O	●	[44]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H··N, C-H···O		[44]
Hesperetin	Picolinic acid		●■	[45]
	Nicotinamide	N-H···N, O-H···N O-H···O=C, O-H···N	●■	[45]
	Caffeine	O-H···N, O-H···O=C	●	[45]
	Temozolomide	O-H···O, N-H··O	●■	[46]
Daidzein	Theophylline		▲●■	[28]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H∙∙∙N, C-H∙∙∙O	●	[47]
Isoliquiritigenin	Nicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O C-H···O, O-H···N	●■	[48]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O	●■	[48]
Phloretin	Nicotinamide	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O, C-H···O	●	[49]
	Isonicotinamide	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	●	[49]

API

CCF

Acting force

Property

Ref.

Quercetin

Nicotinamide

●■

[2]

Betaine

●■

[3]

Theophylline

●■

[3]

L-Proline

●■

[3]

Pentoxifylline

●■

[3]

Apixaban

O-H···O, O-H···N

●■

[4]

Pyrazol

[5]

Imidazolidinone

[5]

Baclofen

[5]

N-Acetylcytosine

■

[5]

Carnitine

■

[5]

Kojic acid

■

[5]

Isoniazid

●■

[6]

Luteolin

L-Proline

π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O

■

[7]

Piperazine

▲

[8]

Isoniazid

C-H···N, N-H···N

▲●

[9]

Caffeine

▲●■

[9]

Lysine

▲●

[10]

Arginine

▲●

[10]

Isonicotinamide

[11]

4, 4′-Bipyridine

■

[12]

Chrysin

Piperazine

●

[13]

Ethionamide

O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O
N-H···O, N-H···S

[13]

Berberine hydrochloride

■

[14]

Cytosine

π-π, C-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N

●■

[15]

Thiamine hydrochloride

π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, N-H···Cl

●

[15]

4, 4′-Bipyridine

π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N

●■

[16]

1, 4-Bis(pyridin-4-ylmethoxy) benzene

π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N

●■

[16]

Kaempferol

4, 4′-Bipyridine

π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N

■

[17]

Piperazine

π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O
N-H···O, N-H···N

▲●

[13]

Tetramethylprazine

C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N

▲●

[13]

Pyrazinamide

π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O
N-H···O, O-H···O

▲●

[13]

Palbociclib

O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O

▲●■

[18]

5-Fluorouracil

●■

[19]

Myricetin

4, 4′-Bipyridine

π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N

■

[20]

Nicotinamide

●

[21]

Isonicotinamide

●

[21]

4-Cyanopyridine

●

[21]

Caffeine

O-H···O, O-H···N

●

[22]

Proline

O-H···O, C-O···N

●■

[23]

Tetramethylprazine

π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N

●

[13]

Tegafur

▲●

[24]

Berberine hydrochloride

O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl

▲●■

[25]

Dihydromyricetin

Theophylline

O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N
O-H···N, O-H···O=C

▲●

[26]

Benzamide

N-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···O

[26]

Caffeine

O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N
O-H···N, O-H···O=C

●

[26]

Berberine hydrochloride

O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl

▲●■

[25]

Pentoxifylline

●■

[27]

Apigenin

Theophylline

O-H···N

●■

[28]

Nicotinamide

●

[29]

Piperazine

●■

[30]

4, 4′-Bipyridine

π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N

●■

[31]

Daidzeine

Piracetam

●

[32]

L-Proline

●

[33]

Lornoxicam

▲●

[34]

L-Pyroglutamic acid

●

[35]

Baicalein

Theophylline

O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N

●■

[36]

Caffeine

π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N

[37]

Nicotinamide

O-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···C=O
N-H···C=O

●■

[38]

Fisetin

Isonicotinamide

C-H···O, N-H···O

●

[39]

Nicotinamide/ hemiethanolate (1∶2)

N-H···O, O-H···O, O-C···N

●

[39]

Nicotinamide

●

[39]

Caffeine

●

[39]

Genistein

Proline

▼◆

[7]

Nicotinamide

[11]

Caffeine

π-π, C-H···O, O-H···N, O-H···O

▲●

[40]

Isonicotinamide

π-π, C-H···π, O-H···O, O-H···N

[41]

Tetramethylpyrazine

π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N

▲●■

[42]

Naringenin

Isonicotinamide

π-π, O-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O=C

●■

[43]

Picolinic acid

●

[43]

Betaine

π-π, O-H···O, O-H···O=C

●

[43]

Flavone

π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···O=C

●

[44]

4-Hydroxypyridine

O-H···O, N-H···O

●

[44]

Anthranilamide

O-H··N, O-H···O, N-H··O

●

[44]

4, 4′-Bipyridine

O-H··N, C-H···O

[44]

Hesperetin

Picolinic acid

●■

[45]

Nicotinamide

N-H···N, O-H···N
O-H···O=C, O-H···N

●■

[45]

Caffeine

O-H···N, O-H···O=C

●

[45]

Temozolomide

O-H···O, N-H··O

●■

[46]

Daidzein

Theophylline

▲●■

[28]

4, 4′-Bipyridine

O-H∙∙∙N, C-H∙∙∙O

●

[47]

Isoliquiritigenin

Nicotinamide

π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O
C-H···O, O-H···N

●■

[48]

Isonicotinamide

π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O

●■

[48]

Phloretin

Nicotinamide

π-π, N-H···O, O-H···O, C-H···O

●

[49]

Isonicotinamide

π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N

●

[49]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Berberine hydrochloride	Chrysin		●■	[14]
	Myricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Dihydromyricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl	▲●■	[25]
	Citric acid		●	[50]
	Lactic acid		●	[50]
	L(+)-Lactic acid hydrate		▲●	[51]
	Fumaric acid	π-π, O-H···Cl	▲●	[52]
	Emodin		●■	[53]
Berberine	Rosiglitazone		■	[54]
	Ibuprofen		●■	[55]
Theophylline	Apigenin	O-H···N		[28]
	Daidzein		▲●■	[28]
	Baicalein	O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O		[36]
	Acetaminophen			[56]
	(Phenylthio) acetic acid	π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O	■	[57]
	Ferulic acid		▲◆	[58]
Caffeine	Myricetin	O-H···O, O-H···N		[20]
	Dihydromyricetin	O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N, O-H···N, O-H···O=C		[26]
	Baicalein	π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N		[37]
	Oxalic acid		▲	[59]
	Furosemide			[60]
Tetramethylpyrazine	3-Iodoacetylbenzoic acid			[61]
	Kaempferol	C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Myricetin	π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲●	[13]
	Genistein	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N	▲	[42]
	Bexarotene	C-H···N		[62]
Theobromine	P-Coumaric	O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···O	▲	[63]
	2, 4, 6-Trihydroxybenzoic acid monohydrate	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O	▲	[63]
	Gallic acid monohydrate	O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N	▲	[63]
	Citric acid monohydrate		▲	[63]
	1-Hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid		◆	[63]
Tetrahydroberberine	Phosphomolybdic acid		■	[64]
	Silicotungstic acid		■	[64]
	Phosphotungstic acid		■	[64]
	L-Aspartic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Gallic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Oxalic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Malonate		▲●■	[64]
	Maleic acid		▲●■	[64]
	Fumaric acid		▲●■	[64]
Tetrahydropalmatine	Camphorsulfonic acid		●■	[65]
	Sulfosalicylic acid		●■	[65]
	P-Aminobenzene sulfonic acid		●■	[65]
	Maleic acid		●	[65]
	Fumaric acid		●	[65]
	Methanesulfonic acid		●	[65]
	Sulfamic acid		●	[65]
Matrine	Fe (Ⅲ)		▲■	[66]
	Rhein			[67]
Nicotine	Tartaric acid			[68]
	Malate			[69]
	3, 5-Dinitrosalicylic acid			[70]
	5-Sulfosalicylic acid salt			[70]

API

CCF

Acting force

Property

Ref.

Berberine hydrochloride

Chrysin

●■

[14]

Myricetin

O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl

▲●■

[25]

Dihydromyricetin

O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···Cl

▲●■

[25]

Citric acid

●

[50]

Lactic acid

●

[50]

L(+)-Lactic acid hydrate

▲●

[51]

Fumaric acid

π-π, O-H···Cl

▲●

[52]

Emodin

●■

[53]

Berberine

Rosiglitazone

■

[54]

Ibuprofen

●■

[55]

Theophylline

Apigenin

O-H···N

[28]

Daidzein

▲●■

[28]

Baicalein

O-H···N, N-H···N, O-H···O, N-H···O

[36]

Acetaminophen

[56]

(Phenylthio) acetic acid

π-π, N-H···O, O-H···N, C-H···O

■

[57]

Ferulic acid

▲◆

[58]

Caffeine

Myricetin

O-H···O, O-H···N

[20]

Dihydromyricetin

O-H···O, C-H···O, C-H···N, O-H···N, O-H···O=C

[26]

Baicalein

π-π, O-H···O, O-H···N

[37]

Oxalic acid

▲

[59]

Furosemide

[60]

Tetramethylpyrazine

3-Iodoacetylbenzoic acid

[61]

Kaempferol

C-H···O, O-H···O, O-H···N

▲●

[13]

Myricetin

π-π, O-H···O, C-H···O, O-H···N

▲●

[13]

Genistein

π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O, O-H···N

▲

[42]

Bexarotene

C-H···N

[62]

Theobromine

P-Coumaric

O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···O

▲

[63]

2, 4, 6-Trihydroxybenzoic acid monohydrate

π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O

▲

[63]

Gallic acid monohydrate

O-H···O, N-H···O, O-H···N

▲

[63]

Citric acid monohydrate

▲

[63]

1-Hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid

◆

[63]

Tetrahydroberberine

Phosphomolybdic acid

■

[64]

Silicotungstic acid

■

[64]

Phosphotungstic acid

■

[64]

L-Aspartic acid

▲●■

[64]

Gallic acid

▲●■

[64]

Oxalic acid

▲●■

[64]

Malonate

▲●■

[64]

Maleic acid

▲●■

[64]

Fumaric acid

▲●■

[64]

Tetrahydropalmatine

Camphorsulfonic acid

●■

[65]

Sulfosalicylic acid

●■

[65]

P-Aminobenzene sulfonic acid

●■

[65]

Maleic acid

●

[65]

Fumaric acid

●

[65]

Methanesulfonic acid

●

[65]

Sulfamic acid

●

[65]

Matrine

Fe (Ⅲ)

▲■

[66]

Rhein

[67]

Nicotine

Tartaric acid

[68]

Malate

[69]

3, 5-Dinitrosalicylic acid

[70]

5-Sulfosalicylic acid salt

[70]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Resveratrol	Phenazine	C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N		[71]
	4, 4′-Bipyridine	O-H···N		[71]
	Piperazine	O-H···O, O-H···N	●	[71]
	1, 10-Phenanthroline	C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N
	1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane			[71]
	Methenamine	O-H···N	●	[71]
	Acridine	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N		[71]
	Succinimide	O-H···O, N-H··O, C-H···O		[71]
	N, N-Dimethyl-4-aminopyridine	O-H···O, O-H··N		[71]
	4-Aminobenzamide		▲●	[72]
	Isoniazid		▲●	[72]
	Amantadine hydrochloride	C-H···Cl, N-H···Cl, O-H···Cl, N-H···O	●■	[73]
	Curcumin		●■	[74]
Bergenin	P-Aminobenzamide	O-H···O, N-H···O	▲●	[58]
	Isonicotinamide	O-H···O, N-H···O	▲●	[58]
	Proline		●	[75]
Oxyresveratrol	Betaine		●	[41]
	L-Proline		●	[41]
	Isonicotinamide		●	[41]
	Nicotinamide		●	[41]
	Urea		●	[41]
	Ethyl maltol		●	[41]
Curcumin	Resveratrol		●■	[74]
	N-Acetylcysteine		●	[76]
	Nicotinamide		●■	[77]
	Ascorbic acid		●	[78]
	Trimellitic anhydride		●■	[79]
	Hydroxyquinolones		■	[79]
Gallic acid	4-Cyanopyridine	π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O、O-H···O, N-H···O	●■	[80]
	2, 6-Bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]cyclohexanone	O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[81]
	N-Methyl-3, 5-bis((pyridin-3-yl)methylene)-4-piperidone	O-H···O, O-H···N	■	[81]
	N-Methyl-3, 5-bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]-4-piperidone	O-H···N, O-H···O	■	[81]
	P-Aminobenzoic acid		●■	[82]
	Succinimide		●■	[82]
	Aminoacetic acid		●★	[82]
	L-Proline		●■	[82]
	Glutaric acid		●■	[82]
	Piperazine		■	[82]
	Caffeine		■	[82]
Paeonol	Carbamazepine	O-H···N, O-H···O	●	[83]
Pterostilbene	Picolinic acid		●■	[84]
	Ethylenediamine		●	[84]
	Ethylenediamine hydrate	N-H···O, O-H···N		[84]
	Theophylline dichloromethane solvate			[84]
	1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane	N-H···O		[84]
	1, 4, 8, 11-Tetraazacyclotetradecane	O-H···N, N-H···N		[84]
	1, 4-Dimethylpiperazine	O-H···N		[84]
	2, 3, 5-Trimethylpirazine	O-H···N		[84]
Ferulic acid	Nicotinamide	O-H···N	▲●	[85]
	Urea	N-H···N	▲●	[85]
	Isonicotinamide	O-H···N	▲●	[86]
Vanillic acid	Caffeine	π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O		[86]
	Theophylline	π-π, C-H···O		[86]
	Theobromine			[86]
	Nicotinamide			[86]
	Isonicotinamide			[86]
	Acridine			[86]
	Urea			[86]
	Andrographolide	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Tinidazole	π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O	▲◆	[88]

API

CCF

Acting force

Property

Ref.

Resveratrol

Phenazine

C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N

[71]

4, 4′-Bipyridine

O-H···N

[71]

Piperazine

O-H···O, O-H···N

●

[71]

1, 10-Phenanthroline

C-H···π, O-H···N, C-H···N

1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane

[71]

Methenamine

O-H···N

●

[71]

Acridine

π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N

[71]

Succinimide

O-H···O, N-H··O, C-H···O

[71]

N, N-Dimethyl-4-aminopyridine

O-H···O, O-H··N

[71]

4-Aminobenzamide

▲●

[72]

Isoniazid

▲●

[72]

Amantadine hydrochloride

C-H···Cl, N-H···Cl, O-H···Cl, N-H···O

●■

[73]

Curcumin

●■

[74]

Bergenin

P-Aminobenzamide

O-H···O, N-H···O

▲●

[58]

Isonicotinamide

O-H···O, N-H···O

▲●

[58]

Proline

●

[75]

Oxyresveratrol

Betaine

●

[41]

L-Proline

●

[41]

Isonicotinamide

●

[41]

Nicotinamide

●

[41]

Urea

●

[41]

Ethyl maltol

●

[41]

Curcumin

Resveratrol

●■

[74]

N-Acetylcysteine

●

[76]

Nicotinamide

●■

[77]

Ascorbic acid

●

[78]

Trimellitic anhydride

●■

[79]

Hydroxyquinolones

■

[79]

Gallic acid

4-Cyanopyridine

π-π, C-H···π, C-H···O、O-H···O, N-H···O

●■

[80]

2, 6-Bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]cyclohexanone

O-H···O, O-H···N

■

[81]

N-Methyl-3, 5-bis((pyridin-3-yl)methylene)-4-piperidone

O-H···O, O-H···N

■

[81]

N-Methyl-3, 5-bis[(pyridin-4-yl)methylene]-4-piperidone

O-H···N, O-H···O

■

[81]

P-Aminobenzoic acid

●■

[82]

Succinimide

●■

[82]

Aminoacetic acid

●★

[82]

L-Proline

●■

[82]

Glutaric acid

●■

[82]

Piperazine

■

[82]

Caffeine

■

[82]

Paeonol

Carbamazepine

O-H···N, O-H···O

●

[83]

Pterostilbene

Picolinic acid

●■

[84]

Ethylenediamine

●

[84]

Ethylenediamine hydrate

N-H···O, O-H···N

[84]

Theophylline dichloromethane solvate

[84]

1, 4-Diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane

N-H···O

[84]

1, 4, 8, 11-Tetraazacyclotetradecane

O-H···N, N-H···N

[84]

1, 4-Dimethylpiperazine

O-H···N

[84]

2, 3, 5-Trimethylpirazine

O-H···N

[84]

Ferulic acid

Nicotinamide

O-H···N

▲●

[85]

Urea

N-H···N

▲●

[85]

Isonicotinamide

O-H···N

▲●

[86]

Vanillic acid

Caffeine

π-π, C-H···N, C-H···O

[86]

Theophylline

π-π, C-H···O

[86]

Theobromine

[86]

Nicotinamide

[86]

Isonicotinamide

[86]

Acridine

[86]

Urea

[86]

Andrographolide

O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O

[87]

Tinidazole

π-π, C-H···π, O-H···N, O-H···O, C-H···O

▲◆

[88]

API	CCF	Acting force	Property	Ref.
Oridonin	Nicotinamide		●■	[89]
Oleanolic acid	Fumaric acid	O-H···O=C		[90]
	Succinic			[91]
	L-Proline			[91]
	Saccharin			[91]
Betulin	Adipic acid		●	[92]
	Terephthalic acid		●	[93]
Artemisinin	Acetylenedicarboxylic acid		●	[94]
	Orcinol		●	[95]
	Resorcinol		●	[95]
11-Azaartemisinin	Cinnamic	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	Maleic	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	Fumaric acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[96]
	5-Bromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	4-Bromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	3, 5-Dibromosalicylic acid	N-H···O, O-H···O		[97]
	Mefloquine hydrochlorid		▲●	[98]
	L(–)-Malic acid		▲●	[98]
Andrographolide	Vanillin	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Vanillic acid	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Salicylic acid	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O	●	[87]
	Resorcinol	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
	Guaiacol	O-H···O, O-H=C···O, C-H···O		[87]
Celastrol	Threonine		●■	[99]
	Phenylalanine		●■	[99]
	L-Tyrosine		●■	[99]
Scoparone	3, 5-Difluorobenzoic acid	π-π, O-H···O	●	[100]
	Urea	N-H···O, C-H···O	●	[100]
	Pyrimethamine	π-π, N-H···N, N-H···O	●	[100]
	Succinimide	π-π, C-H···O	●	[100]
Emodin	Nicotinamide	O-H···O, O-H···N, N-H···N		[101]
	Berberine hydrochloride	O-H···Cl, O-H···O, C-H···O		[53]
	Berberine hydrochloride ethanol	O-H···Cl, O-H···O		[53]
	Carbamazepine			[102]
Rhein	Matrine	π-π, O-H···O, N-H···O		[67]
	Gefitinib			[103]

API

CCF

Acting force

Property

Ref.

Oridonin

Nicotinamide

●■

[89]

Oleanolic acid

Fumaric acid

O-H···O=C